by HookLine » Fri Nov 06, 2009 8:17 pm
Because with the whiskey version you can choose how many 'distillations' you want, from one upwards. With the double thumper version you are getting a minimum of roughly 2-2.5 every time you run it. (Though you could just leave one or both thumpers empty I guess.)
I have no experience with thumpers. So I may be off the mark a bit here.
But I know you will not go wrong with the whiskey version. The worst you have to do is two runs to get what you are after. You are probably better off doing 2-3 stripping (low wines) runs, then combining them for a final spirit run. More efficient overall use of time and heat energy anyway.
Also, that whiskey version has an expansion chamber, and a taller column, which give some extra reflux and separation, so it should do okay with brandies anyway.
Can only say what I would choose, and why. Others may have a different view.
Be safe.
Be discreet.
And have fun.