Page 1 of 1

Thump Keg

Posted: Sat Oct 11, 2008 1:14 pm
by Godstilla
I saw a pic of a still with a Mason Jar as a thump keg. Is that safe?

Re: Thump Keg

Posted: Sat Oct 11, 2008 1:29 pm
by rustyone
I have seen few thumpers being glass jars also. I would have thought this would not have been ideal, as I would imagine that the thumper would eventually get hot. If I was going to use a thumper, I would lean towards a stainless steel vessel for it (cooper is just too expensive here).

Re: Thump Keg

Posted: Sat Oct 11, 2008 1:46 pm
by eternalfrost
if you are going to use glass at least use pyrex.

just hink about it, by design, the temp in the thumper is going to be 170-212 degrees. normal glass just isnt meant for that and the thermal shock will guarenteed break it, if not today then tommorow.

having half a gallon of high proof liquor bust all over near an open heat source is a recipe for a bad time

Re: Thump Keg

Posted: Sat Oct 11, 2008 2:13 pm
by rad14701
While mason jars are reqularly simmered in a boiler prior to lidding as part of the canning process I would also be a bit leary of having one filled with hot ethanol dangling in close proximity to an open flame... I know it's been done, but...

Re: Thump Keg

Posted: Sat Oct 11, 2008 2:37 pm
by eternalfrost
rad14701 wrote:While mason jars are reqularly simmered in a boiler prior to lidding as part of the canning process I would also be a bit leary of having one filled with hot ethanol dangling in close proximity to an open flame... I know it's been done, but...
i blow glass as a hobby...
the key thing with glass is thermal shock.
all materials expand when they heat up. glass however, is an excellent thermal insulator. so temperature changes take a relativly long time to travel through it. becuase of this, if you say pour boiling water into a room temp glass, the inside will expand before the outside even gets hot. the inside expanding against the smaller outside creates huge internal stresses. glass is extremely brittle and this stress easily will crack it.

borosillicate glass (pyrex just a name brand) has a very low coefficient of thermal expansion. that is, it expands very little for a given temperature difference. this lets it withstand much greater thermal conditions then normal glass. thats why pyrex glass is used for baking dishes, scientific test tubes etc and even smoking pipes.

mason jars work fine in a boiler for canning becuase the ENTIRE jar is heated up ant a CONSTANT rate and very SLOWLY. glass can handle any temperature you want just fine. but its thermal gradients within it that will quickly shatter it.

so having the bottom half full of hot ethanol and the top exposed to air is a BAD idea.

Re: Thump Keg

Posted: Sat Oct 11, 2008 2:48 pm
by rad14701
More or less what I was eluding to, without getting technical, eternalfrost... 8)