Sparging a grain mash question..
Moderator: Site Moderator
Sparging a grain mash question..
when you guys do a grain mash you need 5 galons of water but you do your mash with 2 galons then sparge it with the remaining 3 galons.
if you had a big enough drum can you just just do the mash with the whole 5 galons of water instead of sparging or is there a reson for it..?
cheers..
if you had a big enough drum can you just just do the mash with the whole 5 galons of water instead of sparging or is there a reson for it..?
cheers..
-
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 352
- Joined: Mon Oct 30, 2006 12:26 pm
- Location: Ontario, Canada
-
- Trainee
- Posts: 787
- Joined: Tue May 03, 2005 8:38 am
- Location: great white north
I sparged an all malt wash before. What I did was filter the grain out in a nylon sack and squeeze as much liquid as I could out of it and then gave it a rinse with a couple liters of fresh water.
Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day. Teach a man to fish and he will sit in a boat all day and drink beer.
thanx steve and remus..
ok so i can mash the whole lot at once
then if i want i take the grain or leave it in there
then distill..
i have seen this mentioned in other posts about distilling with grain
i recall somthing about tanins etc... if you distill with grain..
1 more question... do i need to cool the mash or can i just leave it over night to cool.. before pitching yeast ?
i have seen 1 or 2 posts were its left over night but mostly i see that people cool there mash... and when cool enough pitch there yeast ..
ok so i can mash the whole lot at once
then if i want i take the grain or leave it in there
then distill..
i have seen this mentioned in other posts about distilling with grain
i recall somthing about tanins etc... if you distill with grain..
1 more question... do i need to cool the mash or can i just leave it over night to cool.. before pitching yeast ?
i have seen 1 or 2 posts were its left over night but mostly i see that people cool there mash... and when cool enough pitch there yeast ..
-
- Trainee
- Posts: 787
- Joined: Tue May 03, 2005 8:38 am
- Location: great white north
Everything make a difference in taste ( and IMHO not just minor differences)
Fermenting on the grain gives you one flavour, sparging the grain and fermenting the wort another, distilling on the grain yet another...way more robust and flavourfull.
My 2 best whiskies I've made to date have been sparged and fermented on the wort and fermented and distilled on the grain.
.......but grasshopper, I have still much to learn....
Fermenting on the grain gives you one flavour, sparging the grain and fermenting the wort another, distilling on the grain yet another...way more robust and flavourfull.
My 2 best whiskies I've made to date have been sparged and fermented on the wort and fermented and distilled on the grain.
.......but grasshopper, I have still much to learn....
Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day. Teach a man to fish and he will sit in a boat all day and drink beer.
-
- Master of Distillation
- Posts: 3086
- Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2006 11:40 am
- Location: Texas
JD im just trying to find out if i was to mash the grain bill with the entire qty of water the starch that has been converted to sugars will be disolved in the water anyway and then strain or filter the grain out with a nylon stocking or other means as Unlce Remus stated..
theoreticly that should produce the same result as sparging, would i be correct in making this assumption or is there somthing im missing that can be pointed out to me ?
sorry Muckanic missed your post while typing this one... good point.
cheers.
theoreticly that should produce the same result as sparging, would i be correct in making this assumption or is there somthing im missing that can be pointed out to me ?
sorry Muckanic missed your post while typing this one... good point.
cheers.
-
- Distiller
- Posts: 1132
- Joined: Sun Aug 20, 2006 1:30 pm
I use a step infusion method to mash so here goes....
For each pound of grain I add 1 quart of water at 185F into the mashing insulated Gott water cooler with a false bottom. (see other post's of mine for the source of the false bottom) This gets the grain to 154 to 160 and keeps it there for a long time. Of course this is for 100% malted grain. It converts quite well.
I open the valve and drain all the liquid I can. I then add the additional water required to sparge.
The reason is that most of the sugar went out with the first draining. The second water is mostly rinse water. I generally overdo the rince cycle a bit because I am going to reduce the wort to a specific SG by boiling anyway. Being there is no grain I never have to worry about burning anything while boiling or distilling.
With corn, I tend to stop up the sparger. I have used numerous things to help with the filterbed but little works except for waiting.
I have had a moderate success using new clean, polyester fiberfill in the base over the false bottom. This requires the mash tun and lauter tun be different coolers though. And it require the lauter tun to be partially filled with water to keep the fiber from compressing.
Mashing can be as simple or complicated as you want. It all depends on your goal. If I am brewing for the state fair, where clarity is most important, I will be mashing and sparging in seperate tuns.
For each pound of grain I add 1 quart of water at 185F into the mashing insulated Gott water cooler with a false bottom. (see other post's of mine for the source of the false bottom) This gets the grain to 154 to 160 and keeps it there for a long time. Of course this is for 100% malted grain. It converts quite well.
I open the valve and drain all the liquid I can. I then add the additional water required to sparge.
The reason is that most of the sugar went out with the first draining. The second water is mostly rinse water. I generally overdo the rince cycle a bit because I am going to reduce the wort to a specific SG by boiling anyway. Being there is no grain I never have to worry about burning anything while boiling or distilling.
With corn, I tend to stop up the sparger. I have used numerous things to help with the filterbed but little works except for waiting.
I have had a moderate success using new clean, polyester fiberfill in the base over the false bottom. This requires the mash tun and lauter tun be different coolers though. And it require the lauter tun to be partially filled with water to keep the fiber from compressing.
Mashing can be as simple or complicated as you want. It all depends on your goal. If I am brewing for the state fair, where clarity is most important, I will be mashing and sparging in seperate tuns.
No that wont produce the same results . Sparging is a hard way of saying rinse.As you rinse the grains you gather sugars that would have otherwise stayed in the grain bed. You also have to figure into your 5 gallon equation a loss factor for absorbtion . On a typical grain bill I lose about a gallon and a quarter (thats 12-15 pounds of grain) of water, but this will vary with the type of grain.decoy wrote:JD im just trying to find out if i was to mash the grain bill with the entire qty of water the starch that has been converted to sugars will be disolved in the water anyway and then strain or filter the grain out with a nylon stocking or other means as Unlce Remus stated..
theoreticly that should produce the same result as sparging, would i be correct in making this assumption or is there somthing im missing that can be pointed out to me ?
sorry Muckanic missed your post while typing this one... good point.
cheers.