I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Discussing personal experience's of getting into distilling sprits .

Moderator: Site Moderator

Post Reply
Flustered
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2026 7:36 am

I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Flustered »

How often have you had something that wasn’t intended to end up as neutral end up as neutral?

I like sipping proofed down neutral and I like to keep a supply of “industrial ethanol” in a gas can so anything I try and fail at will get used eventually but it’s been a rough road to actually make a whiskey I have been happy with.

I’ve turned expensive brew shop malts into neutral after not being able to get a simple pot still run out of them without seeming to pull the same nasty (tailsy?) flavor all the way through the run no matter how slow or fast I run.
I’m asking myself: Are there even any hearts in here?
But a run through the column cleans it up….mostly I guess.
Ran a HBB failure through the column last year :(
Made nice neutral though.

This year I finally just stuck to 100% feed corn, because it’s cheap and I have the large batch method down pretty good, and have managed to get a few BadMo clones full with what I would consider decent product.

I guess the fact that I don’t really know what anything is “supposed” to taste like doesn’t help and that I’ve only started sipping liquor a couple years ago to try and develop a palette.

It’s only in the last few runs when rubbing some pot stilled tails between my hands and letting them air out that I actually detected the infamous wet dog smell. To me tails has always been what starts coming out the column at the end of a reflux run and I never got wet dog from that. Just a weird different kind of alcohol smell and taste.

I did change a few things in my 50ish gallon fermentation process and wonder if that made the difference.
I used to add a pinch of acetic acid crystals to the water because I was worried about chlorine.
I’d use enzymes at the right PH and temperature and dump ice in to cool to proper temperatures while mashing.

I would boil up 1/2 cup of bakers yeast and add .75 grams per gallon of DAP, a healthy pinch of Epsom salt and a few B vitamins.
Then I’d put oyster shells in a bag hanging up from the bottom.
I’d pitch about 1/2 cup of bakers yeast at around 95 degrees.

Sometimes my temperature would get up over 100 degrees…..it’s hot here in summer.


Now, on 100% corn milled to coarse cornmeal, I skip the acetic acid, the dead yeast and the B vitamins.
I add a small amount of DAP and a small pinch of Epsom salt (probably don’t need because our water is hard).
I don’t add ice (I do use about 1.5 gallons of frozen backset) and use a copper wart cooler to bring the temperature down. That’s after using water to top up that has sat in the barrel I use for my condenser for a day or 2 to air out as much chlorine as possible.
I use a large slab of natural marble for PH control….it never gets below 4.
I get it down to about 85 degrees before pitching. I’ve been using Angel Red Label.
My ferment temp hasn’t climbed above 97 on my last several batches.

On top of all that, despite my reading this site for years, I just came upon the information that a pot still run should take about 6 hours…..any pot still run.
Huh, didn’t know that but I’ve been targeting my takeoff for that goal.

3 strips to about 30% and a spirit run with a gallon or so of the wash added.

This seems to be working and when it cools down around here again I’ll try adding some more expensive grains again.
User avatar
Deplorable
Master of Distillation
Posts: 4529
Joined: Thu Jun 25, 2020 12:10 pm
Location: PNW USA

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Deplorable »

When you say it tastes like you pulled tails all the way through the run, are you tasting individual jars, or the blend of your "hearts cut"?
My spirit runs take longer than 6 hours from power on to power off, but from the first drips to the bad side of tails is around 6 hours.

How long are you letting your spirits age on wood before you decide it all tastes terrible?

Im asking because most of my final product destined for a year or more of aging, is too tailsy as a white dog whiskey.
It takes a while for those tails to change into something wonderful, and depending on the method of aging, that time can vary wildly.
Stuff I've put in a 5 gallon barrel with wide cuts, develops faster than the same blend in a jug on wood sticks, and the stuff I put in Badmo Barrels, I don't touch for a minimum of 3 years. Good spirits take time.
Fear and ridicule are the tactics of weak-minded cowards and tyrants who have no other leadership talent from which to draw in order to persuade.
Flustered
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2026 7:36 am

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Flustered »

During the run while tasting and then also while attempting to make cuts.
It all tasted mostly the same.

The last attempt at an HBB, modified based on what my going out of business brew shop had left on the shelves, was not as bad but still tailsy.
I held it in glass a few months until I finished a few more Badmos and it’s in one now.
After just a few weeks it’s already better so I probably screwed up by turning the first run into neutral.

But my point was I couldn’t even manage to make a tight hearts cut for white sipping.
It seemed to just smear all the way through.

I’m doing better now but I’m still not sure if it’s better mashing or what that’s making the difference.
Or maybe I just was identifying grain flavors as tails having done only sugar and molasses up until then.
Or maybe I’ve gotten used to tails. My last couple corn runs were still tasting decent even after they started getting cloudy.

I’m in the middle of my first corn sugarhead spirit run right now and it seems pretty good.
I can taste the corn but it’s definitely sweeter.

So in short I don’t know if I was botching the mashes, improperly running the still or just clueless as to what I was looking for.
I suspect a blend of all 3.
User avatar
shadylane
Master of Distillation
Posts: 12879
Joined: Sat Oct 27, 2007 11:54 pm
Location: Hiding In the Boiler room of the Insane asylum

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by shadylane »

Flustered wrote: ↑Mon Jun 29, 2026 8:18 am

Sometimes my temperature would get up over 100 degrees…..it’s hot here in summer.

Maybe try using the wortchiller in the fermenter to keep the temps down to what the yeast wants.
Set the water flow to a very slow trickle or even fast drip during the first day or two when the yeast is going crazy and generating heat.
A lower fermentation temp will limit higher alcohol production, making less forshots and the heads cut easier to find.
Also strip deeper, because the good stuff from whiskey comes out at a lower abv than 30%
If you end the stripping runs too early much of the whiskey character is left in the boiler and lost and not available for the spirit run.
User avatar
PalCabral
Posts: 2792
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2024 4:02 am
Location: Stockholm, Sweden

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by PalCabral »

Unless they worked in a distillery or have close family who distill, most of us members on this site would not have had any idea what white dog tasted like when they started, so don't beat yourself up about it. It's all a bit of trial and error, for all of us newbies, and new make Whiskey, or Brandy for that matter, is a far stretch from the finished aged article. You wait and you see :arrow:

And that's how I wonder how you can know what you have made is a failure? I mean, either you follow a recipe from True and Tested, or you free ball, based on your own research and ideas. Then when the cut is made, it's a waiting game. I only bottled (some) of the spirits I made over a year ago, everything else I've made to date still are in jars and by the taste of them they are pretty far from being done. Only my unaged Mirabelle plum brandy from last year is ready from all the spirits I have made in this hobby after 1 1/2 years.

Failure for me is a mash that didn't produce fermentable sugars, fermentations that halted, finished early or got infected, a distillation run with leaks, or a blending session where I ended up screwing up the cuts. All of those things are experienced based, you learn not to do what you did again, and you learn what actually works, and you do it again. None of the whiskies I am waiting for are failures (yet).

Cuts continues to be the hardest for me. It's a stressing factor that you can screw up all the fine hard work that proceeded you to get there. Pressure builds up and thus I take my time. One thing I've learned though is to not try to exaggerate how perfect it needs to be. It's disappointing if you were too frivolous with the cuts and you notice the heads, and next time I'll err on the safe side, but it isn't the end of the world. For newbies, the written rule in this forum should be to make conservative cuts to start with until your taste buds have acclimatized. But to all theirs, right, some like fruit and wet dog in the whiskey, who am I to have an opinion?

So how long do you age/mature your spirits? You use badmos, but for how long? They are supposed to be used for years, as they mimic the same time as 50g barrels aging time. Could it be you are not patient enough to wait for it?
User avatar
Corn Cracker
Posts: 1397
Joined: Sun Jun 13, 2021 7:25 am
Location: s.e. Texas

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Corn Cracker »

How big is your still, are using a column or pot riser and what kind of collection rate are you getting, my point being, you say 6 hours but you might need to slow it down a little more, drips are what your looking for. A steady, thin stream might be too much for your rig.
I think I'll go home and fire up my still, it might not make me feel better but, I bet it will
User avatar
PalCabral
Posts: 2792
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2024 4:02 am
Location: Stockholm, Sweden

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by PalCabral »

shadylane wrote: ↑Mon Jun 29, 2026 3:10 pm Also strip deeper, because the good stuff from whiskey comes out at a lower abv than 30%
If you end the stripping runs too early much of the whiskey character is left in the boiler and lost and not available for the spirit run.
This^

I wonder if there is a good stripping run or double distilling tutorial on this site or if we maybe should make one? Too many new distillers seem to think it stripps the waH from flavors, which of course it does if you execute it in correctly.
Flustered
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2026 7:36 am

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Flustered »

shadylane wrote: ↑Mon Jun 29, 2026 3:10 pm
Flustered wrote: ↑Mon Jun 29, 2026 8:18 am

Sometimes my temperature would get up over 100 degrees…..it’s hot here in summer.

Maybe try using the wortchiller in the fermenter to keep the temps down to what the yeast wants.
Set the water flow to a very slow trickle or even fast drip during the first day or two when the yeast is going crazy and generating heat.
A lower fermentation temp will limit higher alcohol production, making less forshots and the heads cut easier to find.
Also strip deeper, because the good stuff from whiskey comes out at a lower abv than 30%
If you end the stripping runs too early much of the whiskey character is left in the boiler and lost and not available for the spirit run.
My solution is just don’t try doing grain in the summer. I’m already using a lot of water just running the condenser.
Also to not get in such a hurry to pitch. Cool it to 85 first.

I mean I’m stripping to 30% low wines, not 30% off the spout.
Last edited by Flustered on Tue Jun 30, 2026 5:44 am, edited 1 time in total.
Flustered
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2026 7:36 am

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Flustered »

Corn Cracker wrote: ↑Tue Jun 30, 2026 12:33 am How big is your still, are using a column or pot riser and what kind of collection rate are you getting, my point being, you say 6 hours but you might need to slow it down a little more, drips are what your looking for. A steady, thin stream might be too much for your rig.
15.5 gallon keg.
Using the 6+ hour rate is one of the things that has been working for me lately.
Which is nice because I don’t want to be out there all day.

During the “failures” I was describing I tried running at literal drip speeds and it still didn’t work.
Which is why I figured I either had a bad mash or didn’t understand what I was supposed to be tasting.
Flustered
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2026 7:36 am

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Flustered »

PalCabral wrote: ↑Mon Jun 29, 2026 10:26 pm Unless they worked in a distillery or have close family who distill, most of us members on this site would not have had any idea what white dog tasted like when they started, so don't beat yourself up about it. It's all a bit of trial and error, for all of us newbies, and new make Whiskey, or Brandy for that matter, is a far stretch from the finished aged article. You wait and you see :arrow:

And that's how I wonder how you can know what you have made is a failure? I mean, either you follow a recipe from True and Tested, or you free ball, based on your own research and ideas. Then when the cut is made, it's a waiting game. I only bottled (some) of the spirits I made over a year ago, everything else I've made to date still are in jars and by the taste of them they are pretty far from being done. Only my unaged Mirabelle plum brandy from last year is ready from all the spirits I have made in this hobby after 1 1/2 years.

Failure for me is a mash that didn't produce fermentable sugars, fermentations that halted, finished early or got infected, a distillation run with leaks, or a blending session where I ended up screwing up the cuts. All of those things are experienced based, you learn not to do what you did again, and you learn what actually works, and you do it again. None of the whiskies I am waiting for are failures (yet).

Cuts continues to be the hardest for me. It's a stressing factor that you can screw up all the fine hard work that proceeded you to get there. Pressure builds up and thus I take my time. One thing I've learned though is to not try to exaggerate how perfect it needs to be. It's disappointing if you were too frivolous with the cuts and you notice the heads, and next time I'll err on the safe side, but it isn't the end of the world. For newbies, the written rule in this forum should be to make conservative cuts to start with until your taste buds have acclimatized. But to all theirs, right, some like fruit and wet dog in the whiskey, who am I to have an opinion?

So how long do you age/mature your spirits? You use badmos, but for how long? They are supposed to be used for years, as they mimic the same time as 50g barrels aging time. Could it be you are not patient enough to wait for it?
Not beating myself up….just wondering how others got it figured out.
I think I’ve got it now.

I had used wood chunks from the brew shop earlier and had decent results.

My first 100% corn that I didn’t think sucked I put into my first BadMo clone….about 2 years ago. It made it 9 months before I sampled it into nonexistence.
It’s got a rum in it that wasn’t very good as it’s second fill now for about 15 months.
It tastes a lot better now but still a touch jenky.

My second barrel had a rum I liked in it as it’s first fill.
I sampled it gone too and I filled it with the feints from the above mentioned rum as an experiment. It still tastes like feints…..with wood.

I finally got around to making 4 more barrels last month and they’re all full with what I think is decent corn whiskey.
I sampled them and they are already improving it but now will keep my mitts off of them and let the barrels do their thing for awhile.

I ran a sugarhead yesterday and have a couple runs of feints neutral to finish so with that and the cheap Costco bourbon I have plenty to drink.
User avatar
Stonecutter
Distiller
Posts: 2146
Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2021 2:40 pm
Location: Somewhere within the Milkyway

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Stonecutter »

Flustered wrote: ↑Tue Jun 30, 2026 5:38 am

Not beating myself up….just wondering how others got it figured out.
I think I’ve got it now.

I had used wood chunks from the brew shop earlier and had decent results.

My first 100% corn that I didn’t think sucked I put into my first BadMo clone….about 2 years ago. It made it 9 months before I sampled it into nonexistence.
It’s got a rum in it that wasn’t very good as it’s second fill now for about 15 months.
It tastes a lot better now but still a touch jenky.

My second barrel had a rum I liked in it as it’s first fill.
I sampled it gone too and I filled it with the feints from the above mentioned rum as an experiment. It still tastes like feints…..with wood.

I finally got around to making 4 more barrels last month and they’re all full with what I think is decent corn whiskey.
I sampled them and they are already improving it but now will keep my mitts off of them and let the barrels do their thing for awhile.

I ran a sugarhead yesterday and have a couple runs of feints neutral to finish so with that and the cheap Costco bourbon I have plenty to drink.
I do wonder when I’ll get it “figured out”…
Sounds to me like you’ve been putting in some good work. Keep those fermentation temps down for sure. Take it easy. I’m tight with my head cut and loose with my tails. Especially with rum. I dig deep into tails with my rum but I age in barrels for no less than a year. It’s been said here before. “Time is the hardest thing to put into a barrel”. And damn it’s true. The wait can be brutal and idk about you but for me, ya build up so much excitement to taste this drop you’ve poured your heart and soul into and sometimes it’s a little lack luster. It’s still really fun and gets me drunk.
Freedom had been hunted round the globe; reason was considered as rebellion; and the slavery of fear had made men afraid to think. But such is the irresistible nature of truth, that all it asks, and all it wants, is the liberty of appearing.
-Thomas Paine
Flustered
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2026 7:36 am

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Flustered »

Maybe I was a bit loose with the words “I think I’ve got it now” lol!
I’m currently not screwing it up as bad and find what I’ve recently made to be passable.
I’m sure I’m only one misunderstood variable away from beating my head against the wall again.

I’m shutting down grain operations for the summer.
Got a couple three feints reflux runs to do and I’ll probably pack it up until fall.
That should give me plenty to sip and keep me out of the barrels…….
User avatar
Username
Swill Maker
Posts: 422
Joined: Wed Oct 25, 2017 10:15 am

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Username »

I feel your pain, I'm about 7 months in and have 3 badmo clones and many jars filling my shed in the hopes that it turns into something worthwhile.

I'm not a religious man but I'm working on faith right now, occasionally getting glimmers of hope.
I'm also fussy as fuck, I love a good beer, a rich red wine and good whiskey and rum, life's too short to drink bad or sub-par alcohol, so fingers crossed
User avatar
Deplorable
Master of Distillation
Posts: 4529
Joined: Thu Jun 25, 2020 12:10 pm
Location: PNW USA

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Deplorable »

Username wrote: ↑Fri Jul 03, 2026 7:58 am I feel your pain, I'm about 7 months in and have 3 badmo clones and many jars filling my shed in the hopes that it turns into something worthwhile.

I'm not a religious man but I'm working on faith right now, occasionally getting glimmers of hope.
I'm also fussy as fuck, I love a good beer, a rich red wine and good whiskey and rum, life's too short to drink bad or sub-par alcohol, so fingers crossed
Keep building up stock as fast as you can reasonably do so within the limits of your production set up, and before you know it, nothing you open will be less than a year old. Then you can start working on enough stock to keep you in 2-year-old spirits while setting aside special batches for 3 to 4 years.
Like Stonecutter, I get pretty daring with my tails cut now knowing that its going to age into something delicious down the road. Im not in a hurry like I was when I started out on this path.
Fear and ridicule are the tactics of weak-minded cowards and tyrants who have no other leadership talent from which to draw in order to persuade.
User avatar
Username
Swill Maker
Posts: 422
Joined: Wed Oct 25, 2017 10:15 am

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Username »

Deplorable wrote: ↑Fri Jul 03, 2026 12:20 pm
Keep building up stock as fast as you can reasonably do so within the limits of your production set up, and before you know it, nothing you open will be less than a year old. Then you can start working on enough stock to keep you in 2-year-old spirits while setting aside special batches for 3 to 4 years.
My production rate is far ahead of what I could possibly drink, I will eventually get to that point, I know it. Like the OP was saying when you're doing this in isolation, never having tasted new make or having someone who know to taste yours it's a bit of a leap of faith
Like Stonecutter, I get pretty daring with my tails cut now knowing that its going to age into something delicious down the road.
I read this before, I've 3L in a demijohn just waiting for that miracle to happen :thumbup:
User avatar
Stonecutter
Distiller
Posts: 2146
Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2021 2:40 pm
Location: Somewhere within the Milkyway

Re: I guess I can always turn it into neutral

Post by Stonecutter »

Flustered wrote: ↑Fri Jul 03, 2026 7:34 am Maybe I was a bit loose with the words “I think I’ve got it now” lol!
I’m currently not screwing it up as bad and find what I’ve recently made to be passable.
I’m sure I’m only one misunderstood variable away from beating my head against the wall again.

I’m shutting down grain operations for the summer.
Got a couple three feints reflux runs to do and I’ll probably pack it up until fall.
That should give me plenty to sip and keep me out of the barrels…….
I’m still trying to beat that old saying.. jack of all master of non.
:lol:
Freedom had been hunted round the globe; reason was considered as rebellion; and the slavery of fear had made men afraid to think. But such is the irresistible nature of truth, that all it asks, and all it wants, is the liberty of appearing.
-Thomas Paine
Post Reply