Structured Packing Quest
Moderator: Site Moderator
-
Novice
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2025 2:55 pm
Re: Structured Packing Quest
I tend to agree with Shady.
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Update: The project is finally gaining traction.
I had very high hopes for these rollers: The problem was this - unlike the "gear teeth roller" set previously, these don't suck in/self feed the strip. It was impossible to make a full sized strip to cut later. Scrap bin. Back to the gear tooth machine.
I got serious about segment dimensions. If not exact, the biscuit is wonky with voids at the perimeter, and basically looks like shit. I had this digital scale in the shop and bolted it down to my cheap shear. I then got into Excel and created a sheet that calculates the chord dimension for each segment location. With this done, it was a revelation... I could cut super accurate segments and stash them in quantity for later build-up.
One final and monumentally dumb thing was, the first couple of biscuits I put together by hand, I dimensioned them for the ID of the column. When I tried a test fit, I realized the ferrules were a lot smaller in ID than the column. Unlike random packing, you can't just pour it/pull it out. So I re-dimensioned the biscuit to fit neatly through a ferrule ID. These are 2" biscuits, going to try them first.
I had very high hopes for these rollers: The problem was this - unlike the "gear teeth roller" set previously, these don't suck in/self feed the strip. It was impossible to make a full sized strip to cut later. Scrap bin. Back to the gear tooth machine.
I got serious about segment dimensions. If not exact, the biscuit is wonky with voids at the perimeter, and basically looks like shit. I had this digital scale in the shop and bolted it down to my cheap shear. I then got into Excel and created a sheet that calculates the chord dimension for each segment location. With this done, it was a revelation... I could cut super accurate segments and stash them in quantity for later build-up.
One final and monumentally dumb thing was, the first couple of biscuits I put together by hand, I dimensioned them for the ID of the column. When I tried a test fit, I realized the ferrules were a lot smaller in ID than the column. Unlike random packing, you can't just pour it/pull it out. So I re-dimensioned the biscuit to fit neatly through a ferrule ID. These are 2" biscuits, going to try them first.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
I'm entering "production" stage:
I was able to make all 4 of these in an hour of easy work inside. Made a set of bins so when I cut segments, I can cut a dozen in each size and have them ready to go.
So... first go will be a 2" ID by a short 3 foot length. I am wondering how best to test them. I'm thinking go with a typical packing like scrubbies first, and at a given wattage input with identical boiler contents, make a bunch of notes. I have VM and LM toppers for the column, could do either one.
Living in Texas, it's now hell out there (108 degrees f.) and all my fermentation/still work is done outside. It'll be a while to make a full packed column, get a simple low wine qty done for 2 runs. Any thoughts on the best test methodology would be useful.
If it does what I hope, 3" will be in the works. I think I have it down pat.
For those interested, materials cost is literally cents per biscuit. The real cost is the tools and effort. But it's been fun!
I was able to make all 4 of these in an hour of easy work inside. Made a set of bins so when I cut segments, I can cut a dozen in each size and have them ready to go.
So... first go will be a 2" ID by a short 3 foot length. I am wondering how best to test them. I'm thinking go with a typical packing like scrubbies first, and at a given wattage input with identical boiler contents, make a bunch of notes. I have VM and LM toppers for the column, could do either one.
Living in Texas, it's now hell out there (108 degrees f.) and all my fermentation/still work is done outside. It'll be a while to make a full packed column, get a simple low wine qty done for 2 runs. Any thoughts on the best test methodology would be useful.
If it does what I hope, 3" will be in the works. I think I have it down pat.
For those interested, materials cost is literally cents per biscuit. The real cost is the tools and effort. But it's been fun!
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- Copperhead road
- Distiller
- Posts: 2113
- Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 4:28 pm
- Location: Brisvegas downunder OZ
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Excellent work BigSwede, I'm following your thread with interest. 
Never mistake kindness for weakness....
- Yummyrum
- Admin
- Posts: 10579
- Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
- Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Sorry go hear the new rollers didn’t work Bigswede.
Anyway , it looks like you are kicking goals now .
Good luck with your first trials .
Anyway , it looks like you are kicking goals now .
Good luck with your first trials .
My recommended goto .
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
-
30xs
- Rumrunner
- Posts: 686
- Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2019 6:05 pm
- Location: WV
Re: Structured Packing Quest
What if you added knurling, or V cuts lengthwise, to the rollers? It would be minimal/no effect to their diameter, but afford a little traction to suck the mesh in.BigSwede wrote: ↑Wed Aug 19, 2026 10:19 am Update: The project is finally gaining traction.
I had very high hopes for these rollers:
Struct51.jpg
The problem was this - unlike the "gear teeth roller" set previously, these don't suck in/self feed the strip. It was impossible to make a full sized strip to cut later. Scrap bin. Back to the gear tooth machine.
I got serious about segment dimensions. If not exact, the biscuit is wonky with voids at the perimeter, and basically looks like shit. I had this digital scale in the shop and bolted it down to my cheap shear. I then got into Excel and created a sheet that calculates the chord dimension for each segment location. With this done, it was a revelation... I could cut super accurate segments and stash them in quantity for later build-up.
Struct52.jpg
One final and monumentally dumb thing was, the first couple of biscuits I put together by hand, I dimensioned them for the ID of the column. When I tried a test fit, I realized the ferrules were a lot smaller in ID than the column. Unlike random packing, you can't just pour it/pull it out. So I re-dimensioned the biscuit to fit neatly through a ferrule ID.
Struct53.jpg
These are 2" biscuits, going to try them first.
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Thanks guys, it's coming along.
I have to trim the ends square before cutting segments.
When I forced the issue with the round roller set, feeding in straight, the mesh tore. I was asking for too much deformation.
I thought about something like that. The rolling dynamics are weird. When I roll a rectangle into the current gear teeth, it comes out trapezoidal as the peaks and valleys form.
I have to trim the ends square before cutting segments.
When I forced the issue with the round roller set, feeding in straight, the mesh tore. I was asking for too much deformation.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
30xs
- Rumrunner
- Posts: 686
- Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2019 6:05 pm
- Location: WV
Re: Structured Packing Quest
That makes sense. The forming is shrinking it linearly but the contact points don'’t allow for it to pull the needed mesh to make the crimp. Although a nightmare to machine the angled tooth roller/gear seems like the most viable option for long length crimps. But I have a feeling that as the tooth angle increased even it may start to want to tear. The plus side is a shorter crush/crimp area that wouldn’t be holding multiple points at once. It would only contact the width of the strip vs almost the entire length by the time you are in the middle of a strip.BigSwede wrote: ↑Thu Aug 20, 2026 7:31 am Thanks guys, it's coming along.![]()
I thought about something like that. The rolling dynamics are weird. When I roll a rectangle into the current gear teeth, it comes out trapezoidal as the peaks and valleys form.
Struct57.jpg
I have to trim the ends square before cutting segments.
When I forced the issue with the round roller set, feeding in straight, the mesh tore. I was asking for too much deformation.
-
Novice
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2025 2:55 pm
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Good morning,
Just reread about your work I did the math on Dixon rings and it would take 22k of them to fill a 5 ft column. I was curious if you figured out the HEPT of your material. Lord knows I don't have the patience to make anything 22,000 times even if it involved sex,drugs and rock an roll.
Just reread about your work I did the math on Dixon rings and it would take 22k of them to fill a 5 ft column. I was curious if you figured out the HEPT of your material. Lord knows I don't have the patience to make anything 22,000 times even if it involved sex,drugs and rock an roll.
- Salt Must Flow
- Master of Distillation
- Posts: 3152
- Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2022 2:06 pm
- Location: Wuhan China (Novel Coronavirus Laboratory)
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Just curious. Since your copper Tri-Clamp ferrules insert inside the copper pipe and you sized your bisquits so they slide through the ferrules ... wouldn't that make your biscuits smaller diameter than the ID of the column? Wouldn't it be ideal to remove one ferrule, size your biscuits to the ID of the column, install the biscuits then lastly solder the Tri-Clamp ferrule in place? The cool thing about doing it that way would be that the packing should be retained by the ferrules and not require any other method to retain the packing.BigSwede wrote: ↑Wed Aug 19, 2026 10:19 am One final and monumentally dumb thing was, the first couple of biscuits I put together by hand, I dimensioned them for the ID of the column. When I tried a test fit, I realized the ferrules were a lot smaller in ID than the column. Unlike random packing, you can't just pour it/pull it out. So I re-dimensioned the biscuit to fit neatly through a ferrule ID.
Struct53.jpg
These are 2" biscuits, going to try them first.
It would seem to me that it would be more important for the packing to fit the column rather than the smaller ferrules. I know that would make the packing NOT readily removable, but that shouldn't be a problem.
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Novice, I haven't tested them yet. This is uncharted territory. Might be a total bust, but we'll find out. I'll definitely report actual results when they happen. 22K dixon rings? Ouch.Novice wrote: ↑Fri Aug 21, 2026 8:06 am Good morning,
Just reread about your work I did the math on Dixon rings and it would take 22k of them to fill a 5 ft column. I was curious if you figured out the HEPT of your material. Lord knows I don't have the patience to make anything 22,000 times even if it involved sex,drugs and rock an roll.
Salt, I didn't really think of unsoldering/resoldering, and it's not a bad idea. What I found when making these, there is a tolerance slop that comes with it. The biscuits are neither 100% uniform nor perfectly circular - they are "close enough" to make it happen at all.Salt Must Flow wrote: ↑Fri Aug 21, 2026 8:17 am ? Wouldn't it be ideal to remove one ferrule, size your biscuits to the ID of the column, install the biscuits then lastly solder the Tri-Clamp ferrule in place? The cool thing about doing it that way would be that the packing should be retained by the ferrules and not require any other method to retain the packing.
By fitting to the ferrule, which has a wall of 0.062" (1/16th) I do now have that gap between biscuit and column wall. 1/16th is pretty small. Hopefully the tab widgets on the bands will redirect wall flow. Given how wide open the biscuits are to vertical flow, I can't see wall channeling to be a big issue. Another option for a new build would be to buy the ferrules that don't go inside the column, they are sized as a cup and don't reduce the ID. Then I could go with a firmer fit inside.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- Salt Must Flow
- Master of Distillation
- Posts: 3152
- Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2022 2:06 pm
- Location: Wuhan China (Novel Coronavirus Laboratory)
Re: Structured Packing Quest
You're probably right. Those bands probably will do something to direct reflux and such a small gap around the perimeter is likely no different than the gaps between each corrugated sheet of mesh. Either way you do it, there's likely not much if any perceivable difference in performance.BigSwede wrote: ↑Fri Aug 21, 2026 10:43 am
Salt, I didn't really think of unsoldering/resoldering, and it's not a bad idea. What I found when making these, there is a tolerance slop that comes with it. The biscuits are neither 100% uniform nor perfectly circular - they are "close enough" to make it happen at all.
By fitting to the ferrule, which has a wall of 0.062" (1/16th) I do now have that gap between biscuit and column wall. 1/16th is pretty small. Hopefully the tab widgets on the bands will redirect wall flow. Given how wide open the biscuits are to vertical flow, I can't see wall channeling to be a big issue. Another option for a new build would be to buy the ferrules that don't go inside the column, they are sized as a cup and don't reduce the ID. Then I could go with a firmer fit inside.
Struct58.jpg
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
@30xs... I think you are correct. After everything that I've seen forming mesh, I think the Big Boys do it in one way... if they use a giant stamp mill, the stuff is going to tear. So it has to be LONG rollers, fed in straight. As the teeth mesh on the material, there is blank "feed stock" on one side to provide material for the upsetting.30xs wrote: ↑Thu Aug 20, 2026 12:20 pm That makes sense. The forming is shrinking it linearly but the contact points don'’t allow for it to pull the needed mesh to make the crimp. Although a nightmare to machine the angled tooth roller/gear seems like the most viable option for long length crimps. But I have a feeling that as the tooth angle increased even it may start to want to tear. The plus side is a shorter crush/crimp area that wouldn’t be holding multiple points at once. It would only contact the width of the strip vs almost the entire length by the time you are in the middle of a strip.
Once they have a jumbo sheet, they can shear it to create the angles needed. I could feed any length straight into my rig, but then I have to shear it at an angle, and this wastes a lot of material and the shearing also upsets the form at the cut a bit. Since my rolls are dinky, I have to feed 8" strips in at a 40 degree angle, then cut them to segment length.
A CNC Plasma cutter or laser cutter would be nice.
-
Novice
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2025 2:55 pm
Re: Structured Packing Quest
I asked a packing manufacturer about a photo I showed him. They told me it was y 250 packing. It looks similar to your project. The HEPT is pretty large.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- shadylane
- Master of Distillation
- Posts: 12879
- Joined: Sat Oct 27, 2007 11:54 pm
- Location: Hiding In the Boiler room of the Insane asylum
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Looks like 1/2 the difficulty of using structured packing is making biscuits.
How about deleting that requirement and make a 2"dia X 36" tall structured packing and stuff it into a SS spool?
How about deleting that requirement and make a 2"dia X 36" tall structured packing and stuff it into a SS spool?
-
30xs
- Rumrunner
- Posts: 686
- Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2019 6:05 pm
- Location: WV
Re: Structured Packing Quest
You could use a copper outside ferrule on top. It’s simple enough to machine out the small lip and have a straight wall pipe. Leave the stainless on the bottom and use the lip for the biscuit to perch on.
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
It's not bad at all once I got the process smoothed out. I went from 3 or 4 two days ago, got 15 now. They are about 2.2" tall, so I'm close to topping off a short three foot column. It takes about 15 minutes to make one, easy indoor work.
I'm hopeful the magic comes from the slanting tubule things that force vapor and liquid along torturous pathways. Another hopeful theory is that output rate at a given ABV will be higher. We'll see.
If they suck or are no better than scrubbies or scoria, I won't feel that I've wasted my time. I'm combining two hobbies I love, and when you're retired, got to exercise the brain, or it withers and turns to Wheel of Fortune and other flat screen garbage.
One final hurdle is the weather here. As I mentioned, everything I do is outdoors in a metal building, it's 105 in there all day, and I suspect if I try a run now, the cops will find me keeled over next to something I shouldn't have!
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- Yummyrum
- Admin
- Posts: 10579
- Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
- Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Go you Bigswede
I really hope after all this effort that it does work better than scrubbers or rocks . If not , we certainly thank you for taking one for the team .
I noticed that some of them are irregular . Are they “squishy” enough that they can still easily be inserted ? I’m imagining that being SS , they are quite rigid.
I really hope after all this effort that it does work better than scrubbers or rocks . If not , we certainly thank you for taking one for the team .
I noticed that some of them are irregular . Are they “squishy” enough that they can still easily be inserted ? I’m imagining that being SS , they are quite rigid.
My recommended goto .
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Thanks Yummy - Yes they are less solid than they look. I stopped trying to weld each segment to its neighbor, that wasn't working. They are kind of like a deck of fat playing cards with a rubber band holding them together. They do all fit without too much fuss, and aren't fragile.
The reason they aren't perfect circles - each segment is .120" thick. You need an integer number of them, so even one more segment would make it too wide on that axis. In the end, you get it to fit, but it looks like a circle slightly squished.
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Last update: After finishing the 2" biscuits, I had the process down, so I moved on to a full set of 3".
Got 14 of them, and at 3.1" tall, that makes over 42".
The 3" jobs are rounder, better in every way I think. The size comparison...
I haven't fermented a drop in years. Once I get my new fermenter set up, I'm going to run the 3", see what's up, report back. For those curious, the material cost for a 3" biscuit is about $3. The materials cost is trivial. The hand work got refined very quickly, and wasn't too bad beyond a hundred bloody punctures in my fingertips. I thought about gloves, but there's no dexterity with them, so I lived with the stabs. Glad my tetanus shot was up to date.
Got 14 of them, and at 3.1" tall, that makes over 42".
The 3" jobs are rounder, better in every way I think. The size comparison...
I haven't fermented a drop in years. Once I get my new fermenter set up, I'm going to run the 3", see what's up, report back. For those curious, the material cost for a 3" biscuit is about $3. The materials cost is trivial. The hand work got refined very quickly, and wasn't too bad beyond a hundred bloody punctures in my fingertips. I thought about gloves, but there's no dexterity with them, so I lived with the stabs. Glad my tetanus shot was up to date.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
30xs
- Rumrunner
- Posts: 686
- Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2019 6:05 pm
- Location: WV
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Those 3” look like a thing of beauty.
- Salt Must Flow
- Master of Distillation
- Posts: 3152
- Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2022 2:06 pm
- Location: Wuhan China (Novel Coronavirus Laboratory)
Re: Structured Packing Quest
I really can't wait to see how this StP works! They all look great.
- Yummyrum
- Admin
- Posts: 10579
- Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
- Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Awesome stuff Bigswede .
Curious when you pack them , do you keep each piece parallel to the piece below it or at right angles ? Or does it not matter how they are aligned ?
Curious when you pack them , do you keep each piece parallel to the piece below it or at right angles ? Or does it not matter how they are aligned ?
My recommended goto .
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Thanks guys! Yummy, I don't think it'll matter too much, but when they do go in, I'll stagger their orientation.
Once in, they aren't going to rotate. The ends are prickly. They also aren't heavy and shouldn't migrate down, but just to be sure, I'm going to cross-drill the base of the 3" column and insert a thin stainless rod, threaded each end, and two nuts (plus PTFE or silicone washers) on the outside to secure the stack.
This would be a good chance to do a manometer test too. My gut says these things are going to have minimal pressure differential top to bottom vs. random packing,
- Salt Must Flow
- Master of Distillation
- Posts: 3152
- Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2022 2:06 pm
- Location: Wuhan China (Novel Coronavirus Laboratory)
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Alternatively you could just drill & solder the rods into place. That will seal them for sure without any external bulk or silicone gaskets.BigSwede wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2026 4:19 amThanks guys! Yummy, I don't think it'll matter too much, but when they do go in, I'll stagger their orientation.
Once in, they aren't going to rotate. The ends are prickly. They also aren't heavy and shouldn't migrate down, but just to be sure, I'm going to cross-drill the base of the 3" column and insert a thin stainless rod, threaded each end, and two nuts (plus PTFE or silicone washers) on the outside to secure the stack.
This would be a good chance to do a manometer test too. My gut says these things are going to have minimal pressure differential top to bottom vs. random packing,
For my 4" VM I simply soldered some copper wire inside the column. I didn't even bother drilling through the column, though I considered doing that. I've been inspecting the solder joints before each use and they've been holding strong. With your Structured Packing, I'm sure anything you do will be more than adequate to keep it from sliding down.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- Windy City
- Distiller
- Posts: 1323
- Joined: Fri Jan 25, 2013 10:52 pm
- Location: Chicagoland
Re: Structured Packing Quest
These are really looking great
According to the manufacturer they should be installed at 90 degree intervals.
It kind of makes sense to reduce any kind of channeling.
According to the manufacturer they should be installed at 90 degree intervals.
It kind of makes sense to reduce any kind of channeling.
The liver is evil and must be punished
Cranky"s spoon feeding for new and novice distillers
http://homedistiller.org/forum/viewtopi ... 15&t=52975
Cranky"s spoon feeding for new and novice distillers
http://homedistiller.org/forum/viewtopi ... 15&t=52975
-
OtisT
- Master of Distillation
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2015 11:59 am
- Location: Hawaii
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Hey Big Swede. This has been a fun thread to follow. Thanks for doing this. Can’t wait to read about your results.
I have a thought about your next build if you take this further. Have you considered shearing disks from your crimped material that fit perfectly inside the column ID? Solder one ferrule to the pipe, stack the mesh disks into the column, alternating crimp direction by 90’, then seal at the other end with the other ferrule. To keep individual disks from rotating and getting out of alignment, run a single small stainless wire or rod down through the stack (Not in the center) and tie off at each end. Seems less likely to have channeling issues and maybe easier to assemble while still using your awesome mesh material.
I have a thought about your next build if you take this further. Have you considered shearing disks from your crimped material that fit perfectly inside the column ID? Solder one ferrule to the pipe, stack the mesh disks into the column, alternating crimp direction by 90’, then seal at the other end with the other ferrule. To keep individual disks from rotating and getting out of alignment, run a single small stainless wire or rod down through the stack (Not in the center) and tie off at each end. Seems less likely to have channeling issues and maybe easier to assemble while still using your awesome mesh material.
Otis’ Pot and Thumper, Dimroth Condenser: Pot-n-Thumper/Dimroth
Learning to Toast: Toasting Wood
Polishing Spirits with Fruitwood: Fruitwood
Badmotivator’s Barrels: Badmo Barrels
Learning to Toast: Toasting Wood
Polishing Spirits with Fruitwood: Fruitwood
Badmotivator’s Barrels: Badmo Barrels
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Thanks OtisT. After a LOT of false starts and fiddling, I have the construction down so that it goes quickly, and makes nice accurate (and strong) biscuits. Got over 7 feet worth of 3" dia now.
These things sneak into the column with very little gap. I'm hoping between the tabs that bend out to touch the wall, and the fact that they won't be sitting dead center - (they'll be randomly touching the column wall in many places), should keep channeling to a minimum. We'll see.
Interesting thought! I have no doubt that would work. One trick would be figuring out how to shear a disk shape instead of a rectangle. I think it'd need a big, very well-made and hardened jumbo punch. Scissoring the stuff is a nightmare, and bloody work to boot.OtisT wrote: ↑Sat Oct 03, 2026 1:08 pm
I have a thought about your next build if you take this further. Have you considered shearing disks from your crimped material that fit perfectly inside the column ID? Solder one ferrule to the pipe, stack the mesh disks into the column, alternating crimp direction by 90’, then seal at the other end with the other ferrule. To keep individual disks from rotating and getting out of alignment, run a single small stainless wire or rod down through the stack (Not in the center) and tie off at each end. Seems less likely to have channeling issues and maybe easier to assemble while still using your awesome mesh material.
I'm estimating 4 to 6 weeks to test. I've had to start over with some equipment, do some rebuilding, and still have to figure out a valid testing process.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- BigSwede
- Distiller
- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2014 10:36 am
Re: Structured Packing Quest
One step closer... I know this is taking a while. I've had to basically start the whole hobby over again after years off, and my fermenter project took time. I've got a nice sugar wash ready to strip. Probably need one more, then mix low wines to make enough for two identical spirit run charges.
The plan is to try a very short (1 meter) 3" column, packed first with scrubbies, then the StP. Handling the stuff, it's remarkably light and open. I'm trying to understand what pressure drop across a column means in terms of efficiency and throughput. I think the pressure drop (differential between bottom and top of column at a given power setting) can be important... just not sure how yet!
To test this, I added two 1/8" FPT ports to the column, can add a manometer and see what's up. Plugged if not needed.
I have over 9 linear feet of 3" biscuits. If anything needed passivation, it was these. They've been cut, shaped, worked with carbon steel tooling. and without passivating, they'd likely corrode. I know passivation has been addressed here, I can go into detail on the why and how if needed. The citric acid solution turned a faint yellow from dissolved iron, a good sign it worked.
While I had the buckets out, I went ahead and passivated some SS scrubbies. Probably not needed, but they definitely got cleaned.
Finally, I'm trying to mentally create a test plan, using VM... how to compare scrubbies with structured packing. Perhaps charting throughput and ABV over a gradually increasing power setting without changing the VM valve setting. Any test suggestions?
The plan is to try a very short (1 meter) 3" column, packed first with scrubbies, then the StP. Handling the stuff, it's remarkably light and open. I'm trying to understand what pressure drop across a column means in terms of efficiency and throughput. I think the pressure drop (differential between bottom and top of column at a given power setting) can be important... just not sure how yet!
To test this, I added two 1/8" FPT ports to the column, can add a manometer and see what's up. Plugged if not needed.
I have over 9 linear feet of 3" biscuits. If anything needed passivation, it was these. They've been cut, shaped, worked with carbon steel tooling. and without passivating, they'd likely corrode. I know passivation has been addressed here, I can go into detail on the why and how if needed. The citric acid solution turned a faint yellow from dissolved iron, a good sign it worked.
While I had the buckets out, I went ahead and passivated some SS scrubbies. Probably not needed, but they definitely got cleaned.
Finally, I'm trying to mentally create a test plan, using VM... how to compare scrubbies with structured packing. Perhaps charting throughput and ABV over a gradually increasing power setting without changing the VM valve setting. Any test suggestions?
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- shadylane
- Master of Distillation
- Posts: 12879
- Joined: Sat Oct 27, 2007 11:54 pm
- Location: Hiding In the Boiler room of the Insane asylum
Re: Structured Packing Quest
Great project making the structured packing.
I've used scrubbies that look just like that and they worked measurably better after being teased out and repacked.
I've used scrubbies that look just like that and they worked measurably better after being teased out and repacked.