shadylane wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 6:33 pm
Is the 30gal reservoir necessary?
The reservoir's mass took the brunt of the energy input, started at 57 degrees, finished at 110. Would it work for a strip without it? Maybe. I'd be feeding the condenser with 120+ degree water. It might be OK, but I wasn't comfortable with that.
My shop has the 240V electricity far from our house. It used to have hose bibs, too. Years ago, the pipes froze, blew up, and caused the flooding (along with roof hail punctures) that shut me down for a long time. Fixing the whole thing was not practical, so we just severed the shop from water service. To get a hose out there now is 150', plus a 75' drain hose. Thought this was worth a try.
With the radiator setup I was running a 20 gallon not quite completely full. It would pull two 12-13 gallon strips comfortably. The surface water temp of the reservoir had heated up, but not sure what the bottom temps were. I hadn’t really checked actual temps. Back to back strips without the need to swap out some water was nice compared to swapping some during only one strip.
shadylane wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 6:33 pm
Is the 30gal reservoir necessary?
The reservoir's mass took the brunt of the energy input, started at 57 degrees, finished at 110. Would it work for a strip without it? Maybe. I'd be feeding the condenser with 120+ degree water. It might be OK, but I wasn't comfortable with that.
My shop has the 240V electricity far from our house. It used to have hose bibs, too. Years ago, the pipes froze, blew up, and caused the flooding (along with roof hail punctures) that shut me down for a long time. Fixing the whole thing was not practical, so we just severed the shop from water service. To get a hose out there now is 150', plus a 75' drain hose. Thought this was worth a try.
Were you measuring top of reservoir or bottom? Having distillate at 91 degrees using 110 degree water seems off. Did it ever seem to try and stabilize at a temp? What was your ambient temp, sorry if I missed it.
Either way it was a success not having to bucket water mid run. Fairly impressive cooling in a small package.
BigSwede wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:57 am
The reservoir's mass took the brunt of the energy input, started at 57 degrees, finished at 110. Would it work for a strip without it? Maybe. I'd be feeding the condenser with 120+ degree water. It might be OK, but I wasn't comfortable with that.
I hear Ya, 120+ is kinda hot.
But the takeoff from an LM is also that hot.
30xs wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:09 pm
Were you measuring top of reservoir or bottom? Having distillate at 91 degrees using 110 degree water seems off. Did it ever seem to try and stabilize at a temp? What was your ambient temp, sorry if I missed it.
Either way it was a success not having to bucket water mid run. Fairly impressive cooling in a small package.
I just dipped a thermometer into the top of the trash can of water. The pump was fed from a bulkhead at the bottom.
The distillate was 91 f only at the very end, with about 12% spout ABV. For the bulk of the run, it was closer to 75 f.
The reservoir started at 57 f. At the end, it measured 110 f. Pretty warm. Putting that water into the condenser, what comes out isn't going to be much cooler than that. The entire cooling loop slowly heated up over the 2 hour run. I could have done a bucket swap, but wanted to try and not do so.
I'd say towards the end, we were approaching a marginal setup. Doubling the system would probably be satisfactory for a run this size. I could also add more water to the trash can I have. It was only about 2/3 to 3/4 full.
It is what it is... air cooling a condenser that has a large temp differential is going to be more efficient that trying to cool condenser water.
Yessir, and that extra few gallons of water next time will help a bit more. I need a couple more barrels, one for a dedicated cooling reservoir, keep it ph'd and chlorinated like a pool, i reckon
I think I'll go home and fire up my still, it might not make me feel better but, I bet it will
30xs wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:09 pm
Were you measuring top of reservoir or bottom? Having distillate at 91 degrees using 110 degree water seems off. Did it ever seem to try and stabilize at a temp? What was your ambient temp, sorry if I missed it.
Either way it was a success not having to bucket water mid run. Fairly impressive cooling in a small package.
I just dipped a thermometer into the top of the trash can of water. The pump was fed from a bulkhead at the bottom.
The distillate was 91 f only at the very end, with about 12% spout ABV. For the bulk of the run, it was closer to 75 f.
The reservoir started at 57 f. At the end, it measured 110 f. Pretty warm. Putting that water into the condenser, what comes out isn't going to be much cooler than that. The entire cooling loop slowly heated up over the 2 hour run. I could have done a bucket swap, but wanted to try and not do so.
I'd say towards the end, we were approaching a marginal setup. Doubling the system would probably be satisfactory for a run this size. I could also add more water to the trash can I have. It was only about 2/3 to 3/4 full.
It is what it is... air cooling a condenser that has a large temp differential is going to be more efficient that trying to cool condenser water.
The barrel has a gradient. There’s no way to cool distillate 19 degrees below cooling water temps. So that means the bottom was at or below 91. The single flow path of your cooler doesn’t have the ability to separate the gradient like a radiator does. I think a small radiator would allow you to see a much better result. I really wish I was set up to pull a run a pull real numbers for you. Double stripping runs back to back at 5500 watts was getting warm enough at the end that there was a slight condensation on the side of the last jar, but mostly water being condensed. On a spirit run the water flow was so much slower that the radiator was able to afford a long run, 10 hours or so. Memory sucks and no notes, but my spirit runs have always seemed too slow compared to others numbers.
30xs wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:56 pm
I think a small radiator would allow you to see a much better result.
I think you are right. A radiator would be better, and since I'm already plumbed for a closed loop, it wouldn't be hard to swap one in. It's worth a try.
The contraption was pulling heat, the numbers don't lie. Just perhaps not quite enough.
I have one more strip to execute in a day or two. There are a couple things I can try to take it from marginal to acceptable.
Corn Cracker wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:15 pm
Yessir, and that extra few gallons of water next time will help a bit more. I need a couple more barrels, one for a dedicated cooling reservoir, keep it ph'd and chlorinated like a pool, i reckon
Some sort of biocide for sure. I noticed a biofilm forming in my fermenter heater loop recently. It doesn't touch the ferment itself, it's contained in the separate system, but it's gross and annoying, and the thought of a pinhole leak putting that crap into a nice ferment isn't good.
https://ebay.io/m/w4uYms This is a comparable radiator to the radiator I used, slightly better as it is 4 row and I think mine was 3 row. It’s pretty compact. I’ve wondered if it wouldn’t be better to have horizontal rows allowing the side tanks to create a gradient and the earlier Chevrolet radiators had opposite corner entrance/exit. At such a slow flow I feared a more laminar flow across just a few top rows could negate the extra cooling capacity.
Good Morning, Thought I mite chime in. I use this 16" rad from Amazon with a 16"high speed 12v auto fan and hang it off the side of my shed.
But as you can see from the ground. I have a ambient temp advantage. My contraption is closed and glycol cooled. Maintaining 18c-20c over
a 5-6 hr spirit run with a 25gal pot and a 4" CCVM.
However as i mentioned the ambient temp is very helpful.
Hope the pic can be turned
MOD EDIT : your wish is my command
IMG_5262.jpeg
IMG_5263.jpeg
IMG_5264.jpeg
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
STILL WORKIN wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:24 am
Good Morning, Thought I mite chime in. I use this 16" rad from Amazon with a 16"high speed 12v auto fan and hang it off the side of my shed.
But as you can see from the ground. I have a ambient temp advantage. My contraption is closed and glycol cooled. Maintaining 18c-20c over
a 5-6 hr spirit run with a 25gal pot and a 4" CCVM.
However as i mentioned the ambient temp is very helpful.
Hope the pic can be turned
First off a 5-6 hour run using CCVM (assuming neutral) tells me my 10-11 hour plated runs are waaay too slow.
Even with the ambient advantage, what was your reservoir capacity, or are you just running an inline pump?
Edited to say I see the inline pump in the last picture. That is impressive without a reservoir. Also, that looks like copper tubes in the radiator. Much more efficient than aluminum.
STILL WORKIN wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:24 am
Good Morning, Thought I mite chime in. I use this 16" rad from Amazon with a 16"high speed 12v auto fan and hang it off the side of my shed.
But as you can see from the ground. I have a ambient temp advantage. My contraption is closed and glycol cooled. Maintaining 18c-20c over
a 5-6 hr spirit run with a 25gal pot and a 4" CCVM.
However as i mentioned the ambient temp is very helpful.
Hope the pic can be turned
I really like your clean and efficient setup. Being able to skip a reservoir would be a huge boon.
The U.S. Amazon has some that look very similar for around $200. I almost have that much into "heat exchanger junior". Oh well. I'd have to locate a 120VAC fan with good power to join with it.
One thing that concerns me, and you mentioned it - ambient air. Where I live, in the summer, air can easily be 40 C, 100+ f. I have a feeling it'd be a real limitation for any air cooling system. Hot air just isn't going to cool effectively.
I read someone's post (I have read a million or so) that the very most important element of all was ambient temp. When I want to cook in the warm temps (up to 22c) I have a 50' SS wort chiller I have in line that I put in a small freezer(full of ice) and slow down a bit.
The system has been working for about 2yrs now and so good ,so far so good.
A couple more pics and my rig
IMG_5255.jpeg
IMG_5256.jpeg
IMG_5257.jpeg
IMG_5258.jpeg
Mod EDIT : lov’n the pics , but to save us all from a crook neck , if you can edit your pic before uploading , it will strip off the rotation data . Simply cropping it will do . Just crop a smidge off any side and they will turn out the right way .
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
STILL WORKIN wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:05 pm
A couple more pics and my rig
The OCD part of me loves your shop, SW. Very tidy, great functional layout!
I'm going to execute my final strip with "air cool junior" as it exists now. I have an idea to try. Added more water to the can. And rather than puking that hot lava stream (as seen from the thermals) directly into the reservoir, I rigged up a series of stainless mesh screens to distribute the condenser output over a wide surface area, to get some evaporative cooling with a little fan. I'll also give the reservoir a big stir at the end to get correct "before and after" temps.
In retrospect, I don't think there's any way to get consistent air cooling of anything here in the Southern U.S. summertime. Long hoses it'll probably be.
special thank you to the Mod for turning the pics. it was quite a challenge for me to get them here.
I have read a lot about closed loop cooling and sadly the science goes by me.
The distance traveled and the speed of the coolant are things to be adjusted.
Good luck with your challenge
I solved the oddball temps noted before. I was previously measuring the reservoir temp at the top, where it takes in the hot condenser output. Today, I repeated the previous strip, but measured the pump input temp, which is fed from the very bottom of the can. It was (and remained) decently cold for 3/4 of the run.
Cold water is denser than hot. So the hot water enters, forms a layer on top, and that layer boundary slowly goes down during the run. Eventually, the pump is sucking pretty warm water.
The stainless evaporative gadget didn't do shit. Overall, the strip went fine for an 11 gallon boiler charge. But I really need a system I can use in the summer, and the way I have this air cool setup is fiddly and would not be effective outside of winter. It's a project for the future.
Glad it went smoothly. How much did the bottom temp rise throughout the run?
That same temperature gradient is what helps the radiator. The coolest water goes to the bottom and out the exit. I never fully measured my flow rates, so let’s use an overkill flow rate. Two quarts per minute and having 140-150* exit temps would be some serious power input. But even on my little civic radiator that would be close to 2 minutes in front of the fan (about a gallon capacity). Your 3/4 pipe has a capacity of about 19oz, and a thicker mass to try to cool by comparison. A radiator tube may be 1/8” thick with 1/2-1” width tubes. A spirit run, outside of neutral, is going to go longer, but have a much slower water flow rate. That translates to a longer time in front of the fan to cool.
Fighting that much hose every time you want to strip, or run, would be a nightmare when the weather isn’t dry. I’d look into a 275 gallon IBC tote that could run all summer and drain when freezing weather arrives.
Point taken on the smaller tubes and dwell time of a radiator.
The "input" to the reservoir (water out of the heat exchanger) was about 100 f. This of course gets controlled by the flow rate I have set for the condenser, with a lower flow creating a higher temp, but theoretically dumping more heat into the atmosphere before falling into the reservoir.
Water fed into the pump rose from 60 f. to 75 f. at maybe the 2/3 done, then that warm layer made it down there to the bottom bulkhead and at the end, it approached 90 f. By that time I'm mostly condensing water, so the run was complete.