Over Oaking - Too many samples

Treatment and handling of your distillate.

Moderator: Site Moderator

Post Reply
Threesixzero
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2025 6:58 pm

Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Threesixzero »

So, it's official: I have messed up the first batch of whiskey I ever made. I did a rye whiskey and used a small, gallon-sized BadMo barrel to age it.

Since it was my first-ever run, I made the mistake of pulling from the barrel too many times to let friends and family try some. Now that the novelty has worn off and I have a few other barrels to sample, I decided to try some of it since it finally hit the one-year mark. Boy, was I surprised when I did. It was very heavy with tannins and really dried out my mouth when I drank it. It also came out a very dark brown color. It is hard to pick up on any real flavor notes in the whiskey at this point.

Now, this was at full strength, coming out of the barrel at 61.5% ABV, so I did proof it down to 50% ABV. I let it sit a day or two to mellow, but I still feel like I have overdone it. I guess that is a lesson learned.

I am curious to hear any stories you guys may have with over oaking a spirit.
PXL_20261120_004554199.PORTRAIT.ORIGINAL.jpg
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
User avatar
Saltbush Bill
Global moderator
Posts: 11650
Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2011 2:13 am
Location: Northern NSW Australia

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Saltbush Bill »

Maybe you can blend it with some that is less oaked.
Threesixzero
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2025 6:58 pm

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Threesixzero »

Saltbush Bill wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 5:06 pm Maybe you can blend it with some that is less oaked.
I will be honest I did not even think about doing that. I will have to see what all I have that I can add to it.

Thank you for the advice
User avatar
Copperhead road
Distiller
Posts: 2121
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 4:28 pm
Location: Brisvegas downunder OZ

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Copperhead road »

Threesixzero wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 4:55 pm So, it's official: I have messed up the first batch of whiskey I ever made. I did a rye whiskey and used a small, gallon-sized BadMo barrel to age it.

Since it was my first-ever run, I made the mistake of pulling from the barrel too many times to let friends and family try some. Now that the novelty has worn off and I have a few other barrels to sample, I decided to try some of it since it finally hit the one-year mark. Boy, was I surprised when I did. It was very heavy with tannins and really dried out my mouth when I drank it. It also came out a very dark brown color. It is hard to pick up on any real flavor notes in the whiskey at this point.

Now, this was at full strength, coming out of the barrel at 61.5% ABV, so I did proof it down to 50% ABV. I let it sit a day or two to mellow, but I still feel like I have overdone it. I guess that is a lesson learned.

I am curious to hear any stories you guys may have with over oaking a spirit.

PXL_20261120_004554199.PORTRAIT.ORIGINAL.jpg
I have a barrel of Corn, wheat & malt barley. After 8 years i drew out a sample. I used a "New oak" barrel over the years its turned into a dark chocolate brown spirit.

I thought it was defiantly over-oaked but i was surprised it did not taste to bad. I had planned to do what Saltbush Bill suggested but i am thinking now i will not mix any new unaged whiskey with it.

I am going to send a sample bottle to a friend that is a very experienced distiller 'SBB' and see what he thinks before mixing it with anything.
Never mistake kindness for weakness....
Powder Monkey
Bootlegger
Posts: 133
Joined: Fri Jan 22, 2021 7:15 am
Location: Michigan

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Powder Monkey »

Some of my earlier whiskeys have felt overly tannic. I have used them for some blends but I also have found that the tannic notes soften a bit with additional time. I’ve cut the proof down a bit and then stored in carboys with good amounts of headspace plus occasional agitation and air exchange. The oxidation reactions can continue even when the oak extraction is stopped. I even hooked up an air pump to bubble through a carboy that was hooked on a timer. I don’t think these are 100% solutions but they certainly help.
User avatar
PalCabral
Posts: 2805
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2024 4:02 am
Location: Stockholm, Sweden

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by PalCabral »

Small barrel over oak unless you pull them early. However, over and over I read about people leaving the whiskey in small barrel for a long time and when they taste them after a few years, the overly oak flavor has mellowed and the spirit turned out just fine. I don't know if this is down to placebo or a specific barrel doing magic, but it keeps coming up from different sources.

If you don't need the barrel for something else, and you've got nothing to lose, maybe leave the barrel with the rye whiskey in it for another year or two? It probably won't get more tannic now, so what do you got to lose except time? Blending it will deffo give you something you can drink now but leaving it for more time to mellow might just give you the whiskey you were hoping to get. Throwing it in there.

Was it French oak?
User avatar
Corn Cracker
Posts: 1399
Joined: Sun Jun 13, 2021 7:25 am
Location: s.e. Texas

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Corn Cracker »

I've done a few oak experiments, no barrels yet but, you can dilute it down, although it takes quite a bit of clear to do it.
I will tell you, you can't distill the oak out of it, you'll end up with an oaked clear spirit that is somehow still over oaked. Over French oaked is harder to get to calm down, i dumped a gallon of over oaked French oak but have successfully tamed American white oak that was over done by adding back same batch clear, un-oaked to it. I've found that oak can dominate the grain in the spirit and not all all grains benefit from it and that cam make or break a spirit
I think I'll go home and fire up my still, it might not make me feel better but, I bet it will
Threesixzero
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2025 6:58 pm

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Threesixzero »

PalCabral wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 11:36 am Small barrel over oak unless you pull them early. However, over and over I read about people leaving the whiskey in small barrel for a long time and when they taste them after a few years, the overly oak flavor has mellowed and the spirit turned out just fine. I don't know if this is down to placebo or a specific barrel doing magic, but it keeps coming up from different sources.

If you don't need the barrel for something else, and you've got nothing to lose, maybe leave the barrel with the rye whiskey in it for another year or two? It probably won't get more tannic now, so what do you got to lose except time? Blending it will deffo give you something you can drink now but leaving it for more time to mellow might just give you the whiskey you were hoping to get. Throwing it in there.

Was it French oak?
I feel I would have to add more rye to the barrel. When i pulled it from the barrel it was only enough to fill one 750ml bottle. So at that point I do not think I had enough liquid in the barrel. I do want to get some more rye and make another batch, sadly I have not had the time to go to the malt house I wanted to get the next batch of rye from.

It is an American oak barrel that I made myself. Since it is smaller than the 1.8 gallon that you normally make for a BadMo barrel I was already a little off.

I did think about just leaving it in there but I ended up making my first batch of Rum and decided that would be a good use for the barrel. I have a few more 1.8 gallon barrels in the works and now that I have upgraded my setup I can make more rye than I did for this first run. I only did a single distill for this one and was using 5 gallon mashes. Now I upgraded to the 58 gallon method that SCD posted I can yield plenty more for a proper run

I do appreciate the input though
Threesixzero
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2025 6:58 pm

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Threesixzero »

Corn Cracker wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 4:49 pm I've done a few oak experiments, no barrels yet but, you can dilute it down, although it takes quite a bit of clear to do it.
I will tell you, you can't distill the oak out of it, you'll end up with an oaked clear spirit that is somehow still over oaked. Over French oaked is harder to get to calm down, i dumped a gallon of over oaked French oak but have successfully tamed American white oak that was over done by adding back same batch clear, un-oaked to it. I've found that oak can dominate the grain in the spirit and not all all grains benefit from it and that cam make or break a spirit
Yea I wish I had more of that batch to add to it but since it was my first run I was working in much smaller quantities. I plan on doing another rye run and test it out in a larger BadMo barrel
Threesixzero
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2025 6:58 pm

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Threesixzero »

Powder Monkey wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 4:46 am Some of my earlier whiskeys have felt overly tannic. I have used them for some blends but I also have found that the tannic notes soften a bit with additional time. I’ve cut the proof down a bit and then stored in carboys with good amounts of headspace plus occasional agitation and air exchange. The oxidation reactions can continue even when the oak extraction is stopped. I even hooked up an air pump to bubble through a carboy that was hooked on a timer. I don’t think these are 100% solutions but they certainly help.
That is surely worth a try, Since the yield is only 750ml it is easy to put it in a larger container and let it breathe
Threesixzero
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2025 6:58 pm

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Threesixzero »

Copperhead road wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 5:22 pm
Threesixzero wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 4:55 pm So, it's official: I have messed up the first batch of whiskey I ever made. I did a rye whiskey and used a small, gallon-sized BadMo barrel to age it.

Since it was my first-ever run, I made the mistake of pulling from the barrel too many times to let friends and family try some. Now that the novelty has worn off and I have a few other barrels to sample, I decided to try some of it since it finally hit the one-year mark. Boy, was I surprised when I did. It was very heavy with tannins and really dried out my mouth when I drank it. It also came out a very dark brown color. It is hard to pick up on any real flavor notes in the whiskey at this point.

Now, this was at full strength, coming out of the barrel at 61.5% ABV, so I did proof it down to 50% ABV. I let it sit a day or two to mellow, but I still feel like I have overdone it. I guess that is a lesson learned.

I am curious to hear any stories you guys may have with over oaking a spirit.

PXL_20261120_004554199.PORTRAIT.ORIGINAL.jpg
I have a barrel of Corn, wheat & malt barley. After 8 years i drew out a sample. I used a "New oak" barrel over the years its turned into a dark chocolate brown spirit.

I thought it was defiantly over-oaked but i was surprised it did not taste to bad. I had planned to do what Saltbush Bill suggested but i am thinking now i will not mix any new unaged whiskey with it.

I am going to send a sample bottle to a friend that is a very experienced distiller 'SBB' and see what he thinks before mixing it with anything.
If the spirit tasted good I would look into that idea but honestly it is not that pleasant of a spirit to drink neat at the moment. Although I did make a old fashioned with it last night and that was not to bad. I am sure it was the simple syrup that drowned out the flavor though
User avatar
PalCabral
Posts: 2805
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2024 4:02 am
Location: Stockholm, Sweden

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by PalCabral »

Threesixzero wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:17 pm I feel I would have to add more rye to the barrel. When i pulled it from the barrel it was only enough to fill one 750ml bottle. So at that point I do not think I had enough liquid in the barrel. I do want to get some more rye and make another batch, sadly I have not had the time to go to the malt house I wanted to get the next batch of rye from.
Evaporation is real in small barrels. You need, as you have concluded yourself, to make 2 times the volume and keep topping up. I take everything out of the barrel and mix it with the non-barrel whiskey. Then put the mix back in the barrel again, keeping the surplus in a demijohn. It rotates the full volume and replaces the evaporated spirit.

But with such a small volume left, yeah, there's no reason to keep it in the barrel. You'll just lose even more to the angels, those greedy buggers. :)
HeyBroChuckNorris
Posts: 117
Joined: Sun Apr 14, 2024 9:58 pm

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by HeyBroChuckNorris »

You say you made the barrel yourself? Did you use properly seasoned wood? Under-seasoned wood could explain harsh tannins and over oaking in a badmo style barrel, which with such a small surface area of oak should be very difficult to over oak
Threesixzero
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2025 6:58 pm

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Threesixzero »

HeyBroChuckNorris wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 1:51 pm You say you made the barrel yourself? Did you use properly seasoned wood? Under-seasoned wood could explain harsh tannins and over oaking in a badmo style barrel, which with such a small surface area of oak should be very difficult to over oak
Yea the wood was seasoned for about 4 years before I got it.
User avatar
Copperhead road
Distiller
Posts: 2121
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 4:28 pm
Location: Brisvegas downunder OZ

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Copperhead road »

Threesixzero wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 4:03 pm
HeyBroChuckNorris wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 1:51 pm You say you made the barrel yourself? Did you use properly seasoned wood? Under-seasoned wood could explain harsh tannins and over oaking in a badmo style barrel, which with such a small surface area of oak should be very difficult to over oak
Yea the wood was seasoned for about 4 years before I got it.
4 years seasoning is excellent, here in Australia top quality mini staves are seasoned for at least 30 months. :wink:

From memory each mini stave (flat broad domino) costs about $7 each.
Never mistake kindness for weakness....
User avatar
Yummyrum
Admin
Posts: 10580
Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Yummyrum »

When I take a bottle out of my keg it tastes over oaked . If I only half fill a bottle , after a few weeks , it seems to loose the tannins flavour . I think the exposure to air helps .

I’ve never tried it , but some people use an air stone and pump air through spirit to fast age it . It might also reduce the tannins
Threesixzero
Posts: 53
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2025 6:58 pm

Re: Over Oaking - Too many samples

Post by Threesixzero »

Yummyrum wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 4:46 pm When I take a bottle out of my keg it tastes over oaked . If I only half fill a bottle , after a few weeks , it seems to loose the tannins flavour . I think the exposure to air helps .

I’ve never tried it , but some people use an air stone and pump air through spirit to fast age it . It might also reduce the tannins
I would guess since you are the second one to say let it breath it does make sense and I think I will give it a try and see what I can do.
Post Reply