I'm reviving this old thread.
It's a beautiful spring day and I bought a boatload of molasses. I can't wait till summer comes around and it's warm enough here to ferment big batches of rum.
Pikey, I hope you're still at this.
I read through this thread and what I think you're after is black rum. Not spiced black like Kraken, but black.
Captain Morgan's black used to be made in Jamaica. It wasn't spiced.
Current Jamaican offerings are Coruba dark and Myer's.
Then the ones I think you'll want are mostly Demerara based, think OVD (old vatted Demerara), Wood's, Lamb's and Lemon Hart.
Gosling's from Bermuda is sourced, I don't know from where.
Black overproofs are available as well. Plantation's OFTD, a mix of Jamaican, Demerara and Barbados rum. For those in the States, picture Lemon Hart 151 or Hamilton 151.
Some of these are blended and vatted in Scotland so should be easy to find in the UK. I bought 1l of Lamb's in a supermarket while in London. I think Tesco, not sure.
Here are some pics.
They're all clear bottles. The Lamb's just for reference of the bottle, I know it's readily available in the UK.
Cocktailwonk has some great articles on Demerara Distillers
https://cocktailwonk.com/2020/02/demera ... t-one.html
https://cocktailwonk.com/2020/02/demera ... t-two.html
Crow is right, they do use a wooden pot still and a wooden column still, but not exclusively. I don't think it's essential for the flavor.
I loved der wo's posting about essences and expensive rum for sailors, I'm afraid some missed the jokes.
The rums certainly had some pot stilled portion, but also a lot of rum that the navy could get cheaply. Cocktail Wonk researched Navy records and stated the origin of a lot of it would surprise a lot of people. My hunch is India.
I bought Veliers bottling of the port mourant double wooden pot still, it's rough as hell. I'm not convinced that the wooden pot still gives any benefit over something we can do at home. It's a pretty cool still though.
Martin Cate of Smuggler's Cove writes about Black Rum in his (awesome) book:
Black rum was designed to impart the appearance of age to rums intended for mixing. The term "dark rum", while in common usage, can be vague and confusing, as it may apply to either black rum or premium aged rums.
However, it' is very important to distinguish between the two, as they have different uses. A black rum may be made using a wide range of distillation methods: pot, column, or blended, resulting in rum that may be light, medium, or heavy bodied. It tends to have little, if any age, but is defined by the addition of caramel, molasses, or both to the finished rum and is typically much darker in appearance than even fifty years in a barrel could achieve.
It remains, to my mind, the only style of rum you should refer to by color, because the addition of color itself is what defines the category. At Smuggler's Cove, we have found that using a black blended rum is often what we need to create the mouthfeel or flavor we're looking for in exotic cocktails, and it plays especially well with a broad range of other rums and spirits.
I love tiki drinks and go through a lot of black rum. I hate spiced and doctored rums, but these are rummy, sometimes tannic like they've been force aged in small barrels, and some have that bitter caramel taste.
I want to recreate that.
I'll start with SBB molasses rum, and I'll throw some in a small barrel or go intentionally overboard with oak chips. Color with caramel and maybe molasses. I don't think infected dunder is needed, as I don't find the Jamaican funkiness in it. I will keep the dunder and make muck for other rums though.