blind drunk wrote:So, can a refractometer measure the alcohol content of a mixed liqueur? Or the abv of a distillate after a maceration is complete and the fruit has been removed?
Good Morning Blind Drunk,
To answer the first part of your question,
“Can a refractometer measure the alcohol content of a mixed liqueur?”, I am going out on a limb and answer, “In the strictest of sense, no”. Keep in mind that I am not a physicist. My doctorate resides in a different discipline though my discipline is grounded in science. The following is “my take on a refractometer.
The very basic function of a refractometer is to measure light that is being bent. There must be a known *standard* around which refractometers are designed and that *standard* (for the most part) is water. More specifically it is *distilled water*. We are taught that distilled water has a Specific Gravity of 7.0. We are also taught that in the most basic sense, distilled water is *pure* and has no dissolved solids. Therefore, when a refractometer is fabricated, the scale on the slide is based on distilled water. The manufacturer may laser-etch the word alcohol or sugar or protein or …… but the beginning line is based on distilled water. For this reason a sample of distilled water is ordinarily supplied with the refractometer for calibration purposes. There is an adjustment screw on the refractometer that is used to “zero” the refractometer.
When a substance becomes dissolved in water, the density of the sample changes from a SG of 7.0 to a numerical value above standard because light is bent differently than for pure water.
I use the following statement to support my answer, “In the strictest of sense, no”. For the reading of a refractometer to be “accurate”, a comparison must be made between two and only two substances:
1. A known substance (distilled water) the value of which is known
2. A known dissolved substance the value of which is unknown
There cannot be a third or fourth or fifth dissolved substance for if this happens, the refractometer cannot segregate and then differentiate the dissolved substances thus the reading becomes a relative reading and not a true, accurate reading. In our case it will become a *relative reading* between Originating Specific Gravity and Terminating Specific Gravity because there is more than one dissolved solid.
When alcohol is distilled, in theory it is purified up to the point it becomes an azeotrope. In actuality the distillate isn’t pure and will never become pure with the process we use because we know that various volatile substances and water are incorporated into the distillate. So when we measure SG or %abv, very little of these dissolved substances remain thus for the most part we “blink”, call it “pure”, and measure with refractometer.
Now, answering your first question in a different way, “Yes the refractometer can measure alcohol content of a mixed liqueur” because, no matter how you cut it, measurement by a refractometer is strictly based on SG and the SG of a mixed liqueur is different from a refractometer that has been standardized using distilled water. So yes it can measure *alcohol* but it has no ability to discriminate and in the purest of sense, accuracy is lost.
Keep in mind that a refractometer is based on a known *dissolved* solid in a known liquid and particles floating around in this liquid are NOT dissolved and will not affect the refractometer’s measurement as it would if using a hydrometer. In this case, the term “dissolved” describes water molecules finding and taking up residence in the intermolecular space between alcohol molecules or if the molecular size of the dissolved substance is smaller than the intermolecular space between water molecules then the dissolved substance will find residence in space between water molecules.
The second part of your question, up to a point, may have been answered above when briefly mentioning distillate. Maceration, however, may be an all together different issue because I take this to describe “break down” of big pieces into smaller pieces, e.g., gelatinization of corn starch. Maceration, in my way of thinking, does not count as something that has *dissolved* in water. I don’t see maceration as a means of breaking something down to individual molecules and making this “substance” miscible in water. I envision maceration as making a substance, that’s comprised of countless substances, into the same substance composition but only smaller. That’s only my take and perhaps, somewhere within may reside a portion of exactness.
Harold