Re: Graham Condenser over Leibig for 4" pot still column
Posted: Tue Jun 28, 2016 1:54 pm
Seems there has been lot of Dimroth PC builds lately.
Lots of ways to implement one of those.
Lots of ways to implement one of those.
The Largest Online Resource for Distillers
https://homedistiller.org/forum/
You are correct Der Wo, I was confusing graham and dimroth. I would like to change my answers to be more in line with Der Wo. If you want a graham (coil inside water jacket), use bigger or multiple tubes, then reduce but a shotgun would be easier. I would actually recommend a dimroth, with the water running inside the coil inside the 4" section then reduce. Sorry I got confused and caused confusion.der wo wrote:I also don't understand cranky at this point. Perhaps he thinks, in the coil of the graham is the cooling water, not the vapor. Also shadylanes answer is confusing.
I think, if you use two condensers, the second one can be thinner without causing overpressure, because much of the vapor is condensed yet.
How would I calculate size on a dimroth?cranky wrote:You are correct Der Wo, I was confusing graham and dimroth. I would like to change my answers to be more in line with Der Wo. If you want a graham (coil inside water jacket), use bigger or multiple tubes, then reduce but a shotgun would be easier. I would actually recommend a dimroth, with the water running inside the coil inside the 4" section then reduce. Sorry I got confused and caused confusion.der wo wrote:I also don't understand cranky at this point. Perhaps he thinks, in the coil of the graham is the cooling water, not the vapor. Also shadylanes answer is confusing.
I think, if you use two condensers, the second one can be thinner without causing overpressure, because much of the vapor is condensed yet.
I blame Shady, that and I was distracted by the counter top guy who I was trying not to try to help install our new counter tops.Hound Dog wrote:Yes, Cranky, you have a Dimroth condenser as I do on my newest setup and my giant Dimroth on Lulu the stripping machine I built.
A graham is basically a worm. I don't see the point in two different ones. Check out the dimroth I have on this one. It knocks down both elements at full boil. A wash will foam and puke before you can hit it with that much heat though.
At the risk of screwing the whole thing up again I will say considering you still want to go with the additional liebig, pretty much any length you want to use will be good. My dimroth dephleg in my flute is 48" of 1/2" CSST as my coil in a 3" diam that is 7 inches long and it can knock down everything the 5500W can do. I doubled that for the product condenser for a total of 96" coiled 3" diam and 14" long. but that is because I am not planning on using additional cooling via a liebig. So I guess what I'm saying is also close to Der Wo's figure at around 100" although I think that is really overkill.Canaanite wrote:Hound dog...great pics...but they don't tell me how to size one for my setup.
I'd be careful, drinking some of Bubba's brandy, caused me to post info that was wrong.Canaanite wrote:Well I just took a drink of some of my peach sour mash split brandy to help me understand. So we are all good.
Yea, don't know what to tell you. That is a three foot section of 2" pipe. I can't remember how many feet of CSST is in the coil. It knocks everything out no matter what but the distillate is still hot coming out.Canaanite wrote:Hound dog...great pics...but they don't tell me how to size one for my setup.
Hound Dog wrote:Yea, don't know what to tell you. That is a three foot section of 2" pipe. I can't remember how many feet of CSST is in the coil. It knocks everything out no matter what but the distillate is still hot coming out.Canaanite wrote:Hound dog...great pics...but they don't tell me how to size one for my setup.