Page 18 of 64

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 24, 2010 10:11 am
by Pamulli
Yea I found a 1watt Honeywell on Mouser too. I found it on another site and then looked on Mouser for the part number. Not sure why it doesn't show up if you search Mouser for a pot with those specks, but oh well. http://www.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Hon ... uuGQ%3d%3d" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;" rel="nofollow

So it's OK to use one rated at a higher wattage as long as the resistance is 250Kohm?

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2010 12:27 am
by AJ Cotton
It is important that any heater control you use doesn't contribute to
this, because one boiler on its own can have as large an effect as 100
other devices. Power companies are now actively searching for large
sources of interference − and a poorly controlled boiler would be a
large source. DO NOT attempt to control a large power heater element
with an ordinary light dimmer, no matter what its rating.
Dimmers rely
on phase switching and not only introduce direct currents into the
neutral line, they also introduce multiple harmonics of the basic power
supply frequency. Both these effects can damage the power supply system.
Even switching a heavy load on and off rapidly without sophisticated
phase control can cause damage. For this reason, don’t use the old
method of using a diode to halve the power delivered to the boiler.
It will interfere with the power supply and the power company will come
looking for you.
-The Compleat Distiller, Pg. 48


I'm no electrical engineer, does Pint's controller have this problem?

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2010 3:17 am
by Kiwi-lembic
AJ Cotton wrote:
It For this reason, don’t use the old
method of using a diode to halve the power delivered to the boiler.
It will interfere with the power supply and the power company will come
looking for you.

show them ya welder in the shed .they make meters have mentals



I'm no electrical engineer, does Pint's controller have this problem?

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2010 9:56 am
by Pamulli
Since I have to order a new Pot I was thinking it would be nice to have an on off switch too so that I don't have to unplug it to turn it off. For the PSR-25 build, can I just put a small toggle switch between the PSR-25 and the POT or is there a better way to do that?

Thanks,

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2010 11:09 am
by snideman
Pamulli wrote:Since I have to order a new Pot I was thinking it would be nice to have an on off switch too so that I don't have to unplug it to turn it off. For the PSR-25 build, can I just put a small toggle switch between the PSR-25 and the POT or is there a better way to do that?

Thanks,
You need the DPDT circuit breaker before the PSR-25 rated at least 25a in your case, since you are planning to use your 4500w element. 4500/230=19.6a at full power. A simple toggle will not suffice. Your current draw is too high. They make really cool din mount cb's for this purpose.

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2010 4:10 pm
by Pamulli
snideman wrote:
Pamulli wrote:Since I have to order a new Pot I was thinking it would be nice to have an on off switch too so that I don't have to unplug it to turn it off. For the PSR-25 build, can I just put a small toggle switch between the PSR-25 and the POT or is there a better way to do that?

Thanks,
You need the DPDT circuit breaker before the PSR-25 rated at least 25a in your case, since you are planning to use your 4500w element. 4500/230=19.6a at full power. A simple toggle will not suffice. Your current draw is too high. They make really cool din mount cb's for this purpose.
So I can't break the line between the Pot and the PSR-25? It seems like that should work since you would be breaking the circuit?

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2010 5:30 pm
by snideman
So I can't break the line between the Pot and the PSR-25? It seems like that should work since you would be breaking the circuit?
Ya know Pamulli, I haven't started mine yet, but a couple a posts ago I put a schematic up as to how I intend to do it.
Just breaking the circuit isn't going to cut power to the PSR-25. Them there are still hot wires both to the POT and the load terminals, not to forget the hot that bypasses the PSR-25 direct to the element.
You are correct that a toggle will break the circuit and render it useless for control of the element but dangerous power will still be present at those 3 locations, unless you unplug it, then what use is the switch anyways?

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Mon Jul 26, 2010 5:13 am
by Pamulli
snideman wrote:Ya know Pamulli, I haven't started mine yet, but a couple a posts ago I put a schematic up as to how I intend to do it.
Just breaking the circuit isn't going to cut power to the PSR-25. Them there are still hot wires both to the POT and the load terminals, not to forget the hot that bypasses the PSR-25 direct to the element.
You are correct that a toggle will break the circuit and render it useless for control of the element but dangerous power will still be present at those 3 locations, unless you unplug it, then what use is the switch anyways?
I guess I was thinking of using it just during runs as a quick kill. It would stay unplugged when not in use. I'll look up your suggestion and make a decision based on price. I've already spent WAY more than I planned on this controller.

Thanks for all the help

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Mon Jul 26, 2010 6:47 am
by snideman
Pamulli wrote:I've already spent WAY more than I planned on this controller.
Yes, but it will be a nice set up, solid state ultimate control reliability, I don't think you will be dissapointed when you are finally stillin'. Now fer my 15 gal sankey...

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Mon Jul 26, 2010 3:03 pm
by rad14701
The controller posted by Spud1700 is not an ideal solution as it is merely a digital "thermostat", not a phase angle controller that can produce variable yet constant heat input... I have researched that family of controllers and they just don't serve our purpose here... Even though they have a digital display they are simple on-off controllers, otherwise refrigeration equipment, like compressors, would fail...

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Mon Jul 26, 2010 3:11 pm
by MuleKicker
rad is right. I had one like that. It cycles.

Check this out, it will make your life easier.
http://www.nuwaveproducts.com/Datasheet ... rev1.1.pdf" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;" rel="nofollow

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Mon Jul 26, 2010 5:41 pm
by Odessit
I use pressostat for heating control. I have two levels of power - surplus and insufficient. When pressure less than tuned settings, surplus power uses, when pressure becomes more than setting, power goes down to insufficient. Setting is 3000 Pa, deviation +-200 Pa. I use pressostat from a washing-machine, it costs 10-12 $ USA.

I use also variant of pressure stabilization - PWM regulator with the analog pressductor MPX5010. This variant gives less deviation.

Video of PWM tuning here.
Video of using test-version here.

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Tue Jul 27, 2010 6:17 am
by snideman
Odessit wrote:I use pressostat for heating control. I have two levels of power - surplus and insufficient. When pressure less than tuned settings, surplus power uses, when pressure becomes more than setting, power goes down to insufficient. Setting is 3000 Pa, deviation +-200 Pa. I use pressostat from a washing-machine, it costs 10-12 $ USA.

I use also variant of pressure stabilization - PWM regulator with the analog pressductor MPX5010. This variant gives less deviation.

Video of PWM tuning here.
Video of using test-version here.
Don't know about you all but i'd rather have a full range of power control. Not surplus and inefficient power. Besides why would you want "insufficient power" that would mean you'd sit there all day waiting for a boil. "Surplus" power would mean you schmear everything. That would be a waste of time and effort.

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Tue Jul 27, 2010 9:41 am
by LWTCS
snideman wrote:Don't know about you all but i'd rather have a full range of power control. Not surplus and inefficient power. Besides why would you want "insufficient power" that would mean you'd sit there all day waiting for a boil. "Surplus" power would mean you schmear everything. That would be a waste of time and effort.
The true jist of Odessit's post may have been distorted by the online translator.

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Tue Jul 27, 2010 11:43 am
by Odessit
I explained badly, and you did wrong conclusions.
Look video #1.
I set the "fork" of pressure - from 95 to 105 Pa.
While pressure less than 95 Pa, a heater gives complete power, 4500 w, or 6000 in other pot.
When a pot begins to boil and pressure becomes a more than 105 Pa, heating ceases and pressure falls.
At pressure a from 95 to 105 Pa, heating changes proportionally from 0 to 100% and set at that level which supports pressure 100+-5 Pa .

I find necessary pressure the experienced way. If pressure anymore, a column "chokes"(excuse me, I do not know how you name this process).
Therefore I support pressure a bit less than that at which a column chokes and I do not give to pressure to go down below, to use a column on the limit of possibility and not lose time.

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Wed Jul 28, 2010 4:30 am
by radar
Pintoshine
I would love to see the schematic of that controller.
Thanks
Radar

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Wed Jul 28, 2010 4:51 am
by Tater
Read whole post then.Its in there .

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2010 5:59 pm
by Gr8brewer
Pamulli wrote:
rad14701 wrote: The rest of the circuit is just as it was for the original dimmer... The resistor goes between MT2 output of the high power triac and the input side (MT1) of the dimmers quadrac... The output side of the dimmer (MT2 of the quadrac) goes to the Gate of the high power triac...
Rad,
Based on your previous post I would think the diagram should look like the below image, but that's different than what Bob did so I'm not really sure if this is right? You also mentioned in a PM that you usually connect the outer and inner Pot connections with the Capacitor and that is also different than what Bob did and different than my diagram? If anyone can provide some guidance here, I would appreciate it.

Thanks,
The attachment Switch Diagram-Rad.jpg is no longer available

Two Questions: Almost ready to solder my connections in. This is my very first project of this kind and can't wait to post up some photos.

1. like snuffys controller, I have installed a voltmeter ammeter where in this diagram do I connect them.
2. I have white and red hot wires for my 240v system they both get connected to MT1 on the power triac. I cant imagine where else would go but i suppose i need to ask a stupid question.

Thanks,
M

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:49 am
by Pamulli
Gr8brewer wrote: Two Questions: Almost ready to solder my connections in. This is my very first project of this kind and can't wait to post up some photos.

1. like snuffys controller, I have installed a voltmeter ammeter where in this diagram do I connect them.
2. I have white and red hot wires for my 240v system they both get connected to MT1 on the power triac. I cant imagine where else would go but i suppose i need to ask a stupid question.

Thanks,
M
You only connect one hot to MT1 on the power triac. The other hot bypasses the controller and goes straight to the element. As for the voltmeter someone else would have to answer that.
I also should note that I abandoned this setup in favor of the PSR-25. I got this built according to the diagram, but mine didn't work. It could have just been a bad chip since from what I can tell the diagram is accurate.

I am glad to FINALLY say I have a fully functional controller built on the PSR-25. I got it put together yesterday and confirmed it turned all the way up and I could turn it all the way down to the point where it seemed to be off. I'll take some pictures and post the build with parts on here. Now for a couple of cleaning runs....

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 8:52 am
by Bob421
I just got the pot for my psr-25. I still have to figure out the heatsink.
The data sheet seems to require a pretty good heatsink. Did you use the one from Newark or did you use a CPU one?
Looking forward to the pics and report.

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 9:01 am
by Gr8brewer
does the psr-25 mearly replace the dimmer chip?

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 9:27 am
by snideman
Pamulli wrote: I am glad to FINALLY say I have a fully functional controller built on the PSR-25. I got it put together yesterday and confirmed it turned all the way up and I could turn it all the way down to the point where it seemed to be off. I'll take some pictures and post the build with parts on here. Now for a couple of cleaning runs....
Good for you, enjoy..

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 9:40 am
by Gr8brewer
Pamulli wrote:
Gr8brewer wrote: Two Questions: Almost ready to solder my connections in. This is my very first project of this kind and can't wait to post up some photos.

1. like snuffys controller, I have installed a voltmeter ammeter where in this diagram do I connect them.
2. I have white and red hot wires for my 240v system they both get connected to MT1 on the power triac. I cant imagine where else would go but i suppose i need to ask a stupid question.

Thanks,
M
You only connect one hot to MT1 on the power triac. The other hot bypasses the controller and goes straight to the element. As for the voltmeter someone else would have to answer that.
I also should note that I abandoned this setup in favor of the PSR-25. I got this built according to the diagram, but mine didn't work. It could have just been a bad chip since from what I can tell the diagram is accurate.

I am glad to FINALLY say I have a fully functional controller built on the PSR-25. I got it put together yesterday and confirmed it turned all the way up and I could turn it all the way down to the point where it seemed to be off. I'll take some pictures and post the build with parts on here. Now for a couple of cleaning runs....
So if I'm understanding correctly it will always have voltage to the element therefore will be producing heat while plugged in?

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 9:46 am
by Bob421
Gr8brewer wrote:does the psr-25 mearly replace the dimmer chip?
No it replaces the whole circuit. It is basically a self driving solid state relay (ssr) controled by a pot.

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 11:58 am
by Pamulli
Gr8brewer wrote:So if I'm understanding correctly it will always have voltage to the element therefore will be producing heat while plugged in?
It will always have voltage, but will not be producing heat. It takes both legs of the circuit to produce heat. The two legs together complete the circuit and cause the element to heat up. In essence 240 volt wiring is powered by 2 - 120 volt hot wires that are 180 degrees out of phase. I Googled that to get the correct terminology...I don't want anyone thinking I understand all of this stuff because I don't. :lol:

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 12:39 pm
by Pamulli
OK so here are the parts list for my PSR-25 based controller and pics. I got everything except the on/off switch from Newark since Mouser doesn't carry the PSR-25 and didn't have the Pot I wanted. You can see how it's wired in Snideman's previous post. http://homedistiller.org/forum/viewtopi ... 0#p6842835

PSR-25 SSR - Newark # 97K7822 $44.65 http://www.newark.com/united-automation ... tt=97K7822" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;" rel="nofollow
Honeywell 2W 250Kohm Pot - Newark # 04F8770 $6.61 http://www.newark.com/honeywell-s-c-cla ... tt=04F8770" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;" rel="nofollow (Note that the picture on Newark is wrong, but you can see an accurate picture by clicking on the data sheet info)
Big Heat sink - Newark #93K7581 $18.29 http://www.newark.com/crydom/he-54/rela ... tt=93K7581" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;" rel="nofollow There is some debate whether one this big is really needed, but since the documentation on the PSR-25 makes it sound like you need a good one, I didn't want to chance it.

That's all that is absolutely required however I added a few parts.
Knob for Pot with 1-10 markings - Newark #94F9955 $7.25 http://www.newark.com/tyco-electronics- ... tt=94F9955" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;" rel="nofollow
Leviton 30Amp Double Pole AC Switch from HD $10 Note that a 20amp off the shelf AC switch isn't big enough since most are actually rated around 16amps max and with a 4500w element you are around 19amps.

Here are the pictures of the final build.
The Pot, AC switch and PSR-25 are all grounded, but it's hard to tell in the pic.
The Pot, AC switch and PSR-25 are all grounded, but it's hard to tell in the pic.
I used the old mounting plate from the dimmer in my previous failed attempt to hold the new Pot.
I used the old mounting plate from the dimmer in my previous failed attempt to hold the new Pot.
It's in a plastic box since I couldn't find a metal junction box big enough for that heatsink, but I'm fine with that. As you can see I added an off the shelf AC switch so I can cut the power without unplugging.

I just did a cleaning run with plain water and it worked great. Brought about 5gal to a boil in 25 minutes and I could easily back it down below boiling. Now I need to do another cleaning run with some actual alcohol.

Overall I'm very happy with the final product although this took WAY too long and ended up costing a lot more than I had planned. The PSR-25 build is a whole lot easier than the other builds in this thread and there is a lot less you have to understand to get it working. I would definitely recommend this to anyone who is like me and has very little knowledge of electrical circuits and diagrams.

Thanks to everyone on this forum that answered all my newbie questions over and over again. :D

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 1:46 pm
by rad14701
Nice setup, Pamulli... What would you estimate the total build to be...??? Without the failed attempts, of course... Looks like roughly $100.00 by my calculations...

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 1:56 pm
by MuleKicker
Wow, that Phase angle module seems to do all that my SSR w/ add on phase controller does. For alot less. :? it doesnt need another low voltage power source. That is cool too.
I know that heat sink looks pretty kick ass, but you may need more air flow on it. you will find that baby gets pretty hot on a long run.
Good work.

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 3:59 pm
by crazyk78
Pumulli....where did you get the plastic box from?

I also had an idea to add a computer fan into the boxes.

This is my thoughts.

I like to keep all electrics cool and don't like spending heaps of money testing my ideas, but this one seems fail proof.

Find a small 240V to 12v DC plug...ie from a mobile phone or other appliance where they are quite small. (you only roughly need to match the Voltage and currnet, the fan will still run, do a test run first) I actually used an old Dell Laptop transformer which is 15V but it works fine just rings the tits off the fan so it's life will be cut short.

Break the plastic case off and you are left with a circuit board with a 240V input and 12V output.

Mount your Computer Fan and circuit board in the box and connect the live 240V side of the circuit to the live and neutral wires on the input to your controller circuit.

And there you have it. the fan will turn on and run when it's plugged in, keeping everything cool.

What do you think?

Re: Heating Element Control

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 5:44 pm
by Bob421
Crazy. I love thst idea. Except In these parts 240v cell phone chargers ( or any wall wart type of power supply) are plenty rare. All ours are 120v. I wonder if It would mess things up to steal power off of one leg and ground. One of those little things wouldn't pull much juice. And I would love to have a small fan in the box.