Dangers of Methanol: Something to worry about?
Posted: Fri Jul 29, 2011 12:41 pm
To all the gentlemen of this fine forum.
First off allow me to begin by saying that there truly is no other community (online or offline) much like this one. The exchange of knowledge here is invaluable. I stumbled on this site after digging around the web for a good rum recipe. I looked at Pugi's Rum and thought I was set, but I was wrong. What ensued were weeks of intense and deep (meditative like) home distillation research. I dug through every corner of the forum and soaked up as much as I could from every section before I decided to go at it myself. And I must admit, I am one ecstatic camper! Seriously the results have everyone raving. But the issue of ever producing a botched "blinding" drink was still in the back of my mind, I just couldn't shake it. So I did some more research.
Pure Methanol in as little as 15mL can cause blindness, and as much as 30 mL of it can potentially be fatal (30ml is about 2/3 of a shot). Now thats scary to think, but since we discard the foreshots, which contain the bulk (if any) of the methanol produced, then we should be safe. In the extreme case of methanol poisoning, the effects of which can take hours to set in, an antidote could help to save someone's life and even prevent blindness. The blindness, by the way, causes permanent blindness by destruction of the optical nerve (ouch!). But if an antidote is take soon enough, then you should be fine, but how to get my hands on the antidote?
It turns out that the antidote, Fomepizole, is something a doctor has to prescribe, so a quick trip to the local pharmacy won't help. That just broke my heart thinking my plans of an 'emergency glass antidote box' were shattered (pardon the pun). It wasn't until a rerun episode of House on tv that caught my attention. An inmate was admitted to the hospital and it was later found that he tried to kill himself by ingesting methanol (in the form of ink toner). House saves his life in a MacGyveresc way (as he always does) by having him drink Tequila!
It turns out that an antidote of methanol poising is infect ethanol. Ethanol works as an antidote by competitively inhibiting methanol from metabolizing in the body by means of alcohol hydrogenase (fancy word for alcohol to aldehyde conversion in the body). This allows for methanol to be excreted and urinated out. That means that we're producing the poison and antidote together. So basically if methanol fore shots were not thrown out in proportionate amounts to the alcohol collected, if the methanol were collected in a vat with at least twice the amount of methanol, then that ethanol would in effect act as an antidote.
To make things clear, I am in no way condoning keeping fore shots, in fact I actually throw out more than I should to lower the chances of any methanol effects (hangovers, etc.) I just thought it was relevant information and worth sharing with any freshman distillers that were worried about Methanol as much as I was.
First off allow me to begin by saying that there truly is no other community (online or offline) much like this one. The exchange of knowledge here is invaluable. I stumbled on this site after digging around the web for a good rum recipe. I looked at Pugi's Rum and thought I was set, but I was wrong. What ensued were weeks of intense and deep (meditative like) home distillation research. I dug through every corner of the forum and soaked up as much as I could from every section before I decided to go at it myself. And I must admit, I am one ecstatic camper! Seriously the results have everyone raving. But the issue of ever producing a botched "blinding" drink was still in the back of my mind, I just couldn't shake it. So I did some more research.
Pure Methanol in as little as 15mL can cause blindness, and as much as 30 mL of it can potentially be fatal (30ml is about 2/3 of a shot). Now thats scary to think, but since we discard the foreshots, which contain the bulk (if any) of the methanol produced, then we should be safe. In the extreme case of methanol poisoning, the effects of which can take hours to set in, an antidote could help to save someone's life and even prevent blindness. The blindness, by the way, causes permanent blindness by destruction of the optical nerve (ouch!). But if an antidote is take soon enough, then you should be fine, but how to get my hands on the antidote?
It turns out that the antidote, Fomepizole, is something a doctor has to prescribe, so a quick trip to the local pharmacy won't help. That just broke my heart thinking my plans of an 'emergency glass antidote box' were shattered (pardon the pun). It wasn't until a rerun episode of House on tv that caught my attention. An inmate was admitted to the hospital and it was later found that he tried to kill himself by ingesting methanol (in the form of ink toner). House saves his life in a MacGyveresc way (as he always does) by having him drink Tequila!
It turns out that an antidote of methanol poising is infect ethanol. Ethanol works as an antidote by competitively inhibiting methanol from metabolizing in the body by means of alcohol hydrogenase (fancy word for alcohol to aldehyde conversion in the body). This allows for methanol to be excreted and urinated out. That means that we're producing the poison and antidote together. So basically if methanol fore shots were not thrown out in proportionate amounts to the alcohol collected, if the methanol were collected in a vat with at least twice the amount of methanol, then that ethanol would in effect act as an antidote.
To make things clear, I am in no way condoning keeping fore shots, in fact I actually throw out more than I should to lower the chances of any methanol effects (hangovers, etc.) I just thought it was relevant information and worth sharing with any freshman distillers that were worried about Methanol as much as I was.