cannon.co.tn wrote:if aging liquor is like aging beer and wine in wood one of the aspects missed in using wood chips or staves shoved into a glass bottle is the oxygen interchange. Barrels act as a barrier/filter to oxygen hitting the liquid.
The interaction between char(coal), wood, oxygen and beer/wine is where the magic lies. Putting wood chips into a glass bottle deprives your liquid of Oxygen which it needs to age properly and leaving the top open doesn't regulate the oxygen interchange and doesn't allow for oxygen/wood/liquid to all meet in one place. This is an extremely important aspect to aging beer or wine on wood.
I have no experience with liquor but I suspect that it is a similar problem with trying to age in a bottle with wood tossed in. I've toyed with the idea of using a large mouth jar and creating a wooden top for it so that I can get the proper interfacing of wood/oxygen/beer but there is no way to get enough surface area with this approach. I think I may be stuck with looking for old barrels. I just can't imagine getting enough beer together to age in a full barrel, much less spirits!
The other problem with using wood chips is that once charred there isn't enough wood content left for extraction so it does take larger pieces of wood if you want any sort of effect.
I know that some folks who make sour beers use conical pieces of wood stuck into a carboy far enough to contact the beer. The wood is inoculated with brett or whatever bug they want. This way the beer wicks up the wood and the air gets in through the wood.
This may be part of the "magic" I get when I distress age. I only fill my jugs about 2/3 full, and I shake the hell out of it every day (when I rotate between freezer and outside. I also open the jug, and "cycle" the air, before and after shaking.
The shaking will put LOTS of bubbles into the product, thus infusing some O2 into it. This may be a lot of the "speedup" that I am seeing, and the cold/hot transitions may play a smaller roll than I had originally thought.
Whatever it is, I know that the steps I take (alternate between freezer and warm every 24 hours, and shake the jugs, and "replace" the air in the jug), certainly sped up and vastly improved the 'aging' over a product that was simply put into jugs (with the same amount of split staves), and simply set in the basement to "age".
I am sure that mileage will vary, but I will continue forward with "this" method, as it works for me.
I can (and will) test this out, by using O2 from my welding setup, to put pure O2 into 4 jugs, and "air" into 4 others. Then age two O2 and two air, garage, shaking both, but not changing out the contents of two of them (one O2 and one air), and the other 2 get their air and O2 changed. Then the other 4 into the freezer (and out). Again, shaking all, but only changing the air and O2 in one set. Then compare the 8 jugs at 4 weeks, 6 weeks, 8 weeks, and 10 weeks. I have somewhere around 17 gallons of low wines of some UJSM in 3 carboys, so I should have product for this test.
This has been a VERY nice thread so far.
H.