For the most part I used fancy molasses and brown sugar. Some batches I backseted, others I didn't. I let some of it age (drank some it hot of the still - there was a few really yummy bottles) and had some friends over to taste test.
I have come to the following conclusions
1) Don't use the oak shavings for oaking wine. These bottles just seemed to leave a sediment mess. Good thing I only did a few bottles like that.
2) Cinnamon is a very strong spice. Use very little when trying to make a spiced rum.


3) When inviting friends over for a rum tasting, this rapidly degenerates into drinking.


4) I have to keep better records. The 5 star bottles I have no idea what exactly was the process.
Overall, then trend seemed to be bottles that were made later were better then bottles I made while still learning. I attribute the better tasting stuff to better cuts and a handy supply of feints from previous runs.
I just started my new batch of the season. Keeping better records and I have the confidence to go out and get an oak barrel for better aging.
Tonight's batch is inspired by reading pinto's fast ferment rum
6 x 640g Fancy Molasses
1kg brown sugar
1/4 cup active dry yeast
2 Women's multivitamins
1 tsp citric acid
5 tsp DAP
1 pkg EC-1118 yeast
In a small pot boil about 4L of water, add brown sugar, citric acid, DAP and 1/4 cup active dry yeast. Boiled for 45 minutes.
Add to carboy, add fancy molasses, top up with spring water to 20L mark on carboy. Power drill mix vigorously introducing as much O2 as possible. SG reading was 1.08
Rehydrate and pitch yeast.
Stop staring at it waiting for magic to happen, make a drink with the 5 star stuff and post at Home Disitller
