Welding versus soldering

[rickyaifd]

I'm sure it's been discussed and even with all my reading, I've probably overlooked it, but what safety issues are related with welding of copper versus soldering of copper?

[Blarney Stoned]

When done in a well vented area, none.

With proper fitment and a well executed procedure, none.

JMHO

[rickyaifd]

Guess I should have specified a little more... safety in regards to food and drink safety...would welding affect the consumable alcohols ... I know we use food safe solders...that was my concern.

[acfixer69]

After proper cleaning they are both safe.

AC

[Pikey]

Soldering is likely to be much easier and you can take it apart after.

Had to give up my oxy-acetylene, so all I have now is mig, stick or carbon arc - I don't think I'm good enough to weld copper gas-tight with any of those !

[nuntius01]

as long as you clean well. there is no difference. structurally, in general, welding is stronger if done right. however, soldering is more attainable for the average person.

[BugHunter]

If you need more strength than soldering, you need to quit climbing on your still.

[Pikey]

If you need more strength than soldering, you need to quit climbing on your still.

Yup !