While this case is taking place in Kentucky.
Cheers!
Moderator: Site Moderator
I do believe you are right 8Ball, unfortunately we, all home distillers in the USA, Canada and other countries, are up against monopoly protection. The big distillers want to sell and control every drop of spirits sold. The Government wants its cut on every ml/oz sold. The easiest way for gov to do that is limit who is producing and selling.8Ball wrote: ↑Fri Mar 13, 2026 3:44 pm I’m pretty sure the loss of tax revenues collected on commercial spirits will be the big hurdle to jump in order for home distilling to become legal in the US.
Otherwise, I’m pretty confident that the feds are not worried about me discretely making my own hobby scale spirits for private consumption, i.e., not for sale.
Wait ….. do you have to vote who is your sheriff
This is also my position. I'm no longer super secretive about it, but I don't flaunt it either. Most of the people in my social circle know what I do, but I also keep my circle pretty small intentionally.8Ball wrote: ↑Fri Mar 13, 2026 3:44 pm I’m pretty sure the loss of tax revenues collected on commercial spirits will be the big hurdle to jump in order for home distilling to become legal in the US.
Otherwise, I’m pretty confident that the feds are not worried about me discretely making my own hobby scale spirits for private consumption, i.e., not for sale.
This case was in the 5th circuit. The case in the OP is in front of the 6th circuit. IF this court rules the same as the 5th circuit, then we are one step closer to lifting the ban nationwide.
I'm not sure when the court will hear the oral arguments, but Rick, from the HDA has been giving updates on the HDA YouTube channel. Being as they are one of the lead plaintiffs; I subscribed to his channel. I'm especially intrigued on the outcome of this case, and the implications a positive ruling could have on other regulatory taxation schemes, under the "Necessary and Proper Clause."The Booze Pipe wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 7:49 am I saw a spot on the local news about this going to the supreme court. Any idea where things are at?
Yes, how this case is ruled could significantly scale back government. Last I saw I think oral arguments are the first of the year. This, and the semi auto ban, case are two I am watching closely.Deplorable wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 8:43 am
I'm not sure when the court will hear the oral arguments, but Rick, from the HDA has been giving updates on the HDA YouTube channel. Being as they are one of the lead plaintiffs; I subscribed to his channel. I'm especially intrigued on the outcome of this case, and the implications a positive ruling could have on other regulatory taxation schemes, under the "Necessary and Proper Clause."
If that one interests you as well, there is a good 2A lawyer out of Washington state that posts regular videos that he keeps to under 15 minutes, William Kirk at Washington Gun Law does a great job of breaking down all of the cases on the 2A. As a matter of fact, he recently put out a video about the HDA case and brought up how it could impact the NFA.subbrew wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 2:03 pmYes, how this case is ruled could significantly scale back government. Last I saw I think oral arguments are the first of the year. This, and the semi auto ban, case are two I am watching closely.Deplorable wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 8:43 am
I'm not sure when the court will hear the oral arguments, but Rick, from the HDA has been giving updates on the HDA YouTube channel. Being as they are one of the lead plaintiffs; I subscribed to his channel. I'm especially intrigued on the outcome of this case, and the implications a positive ruling could have on other regulatory taxation schemes, under the "Necessary and Proper Clause."
"Give me the man, and I'll give you his crime" -Lavrentiy Beria
I do watch William's videos. Do a search for Joe Huffman and Boomershoot. Joe puts out a daily (more or less) email with relevant topics. You might want to sign up for it. Another daily email I get is the Volokh Conspiracy email. It is specifically about court cases and Stephen Halbrook often has a post in it about 2A cases.Deplorable wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2026 11:50 am
If that one interests you as well, there is a good 2A lawyer out of Washington state that posts regular videos that he keeps to under 15 minutes, William Kirk at Washington Gun Law does a great job of breaking down all of the cases on the 2A. As a matter of fact, he recently put out a video about the HDA case and brought up how it could impact the NFA.