Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Vapor, Liquid or Cooling Management. Flutes, plates, etc.

Moderator: Site Moderator

User avatar
shadylane
Master of Distillation
Posts: 12872
Joined: Sat Oct 27, 2007 11:54 pm
Location: Hiding In the Boiler room of the Insane asylum

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by shadylane »

The best "tails trap" I've found doesn't need any additional equipment.
All that's needed is a stripping run. :wink:
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

Saltbush Bill wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 2:49 am Imo ball or plate size will be less important than having a down commer / down commers that can easily handle the volume of returning reflux.
That will be the bottleneck in the system, Id go 3 inch minimum. Perforated plates or bubble caps that are even remotely flooded will always preform at way less than optimum and will let tails through. Id also suggest that at the speed that a normal 2 inch reflux column can process quality booze that a 4 inch plate is probably not necessary.....again downcomer performance is what will dictate the outcome.
Thanks Bill. Exactly the kind of feedback I'm interested in.
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

shadylane wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 5:52 am If you're going to use the plate for a tails trap. It would be best if it was big and driven gently.
The tails trap is the particular focus in this thought/experiment. Yep.
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

LWTCS wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 6:09 am The bubbleball concept is not really about a tails trap at all.

It's more to do with boosting the proof of what is feeding the column.
You're right. My reply to DrMiller was poorly incomplete.

I should have said, of the various properties of a bubble ball the potential trapping of tails is the area of interest to me. Not its other factors.
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

Ben wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 6:13 am
andrew_987789 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 7:17 pm
By the nature of it's design a 2" bubble plate is going to have lower rate of vapor throughput compared to the column, I'm sure.
Incorrect. You will produce the same volume of vapor for a given heat input regardless of the diameter of the system, the vapor speed increases if the available cross section decreases. This is true as long as you aren't pressurizing the system. Liquid behavior coming back down is a different story.
I'm not talking about the amount of vapour produced by the boiler. I'm talking about the amount of vapor that will pass through a 2" bubble plate without additional resistance/back pressure as compared to packed column.
User avatar
LWTCS
Site Mod
Posts: 13301
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 6:04 pm
Location: Treasure Coast

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by LWTCS »

If you click back on the table I posted it should be a bit more clear.
Trample the injured and hurdle the dead.
User avatar
TwoSheds
Rumrunner
Posts: 587
Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2021 5:49 pm
Location: New England, USA

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by TwoSheds »

LWTCS wrote: ↑Tue Aug 02, 2022 3:14 am If you click back on the table I posted it should be a bit more clear.
Much better. Thanks.

Trying to interpret your results, did you end up with more fusels in the output with the 6 plate than with 2 plates or pot (none)?
User avatar
LWTCS
Site Mod
Posts: 13301
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 6:04 pm
Location: Treasure Coast

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by LWTCS »

TwoSheds wrote: ↑Tue Aug 02, 2022 5:37 am
LWTCS wrote: ↑Tue Aug 02, 2022 3:14 am If you click back on the table I posted it should be a bit more clear.
Much better. Thanks.

Trying to interpret your results, did you end up with more fusels in the output with the 6 plate than with 2 plates or pot (none)?
Hi TwoSheds,
On the Distilled Beverage Panel we can see that increasing the distillation cycles associated with the higher plate count reduces Acetaldehyde, Methanol, and Ethyl Acetate. That seems quite consistent with the anecdotal information found through out the forum as plated column use became popular. And packed columns too for that matter. Basically more plates (actual or theoretical) equals a thinner finished spirit on paper.
Then on the Fusel Oils panel we can see a steady increase in nearly all fusels, particularly with the 6 plate column.

I do find that the reduction in n-Propanol, Isobutanol, Isoamyl Alcohol and Active Amyl Alcohol with the two plate column very interesting and have no idea precisely why that happens compared to the marked increase of the 6 plate column?
I can only assume the the equalization period often used on the taller column was proportionately longer? Or that the heat needed to drive vapor to maintain uniform collection speed was that much greater for the 6 plate column and therefore the added heat may have pushed proportionately more fusel constituents into the taller column as the run progressed?
Dunno?
Trample the injured and hurdle the dead.
User avatar
TwoSheds
Rumrunner
Posts: 587
Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2021 5:49 pm
Location: New England, USA

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by TwoSheds »

All very interesting and it supports the use of plated columns for flavored spirits, especially if they are to be consumed white.

The reduction on 2 plates caught my eye too. Your hypotheses seem feasible but more experiments would probably be needed to fully vet those. Wish I had the time/resources to do that!

Thanks again.

TwoSheds.
User avatar
LWTCS
Site Mod
Posts: 13301
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 6:04 pm
Location: Treasure Coast

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by LWTCS »

TwoSheds wrote: ↑Tue Aug 02, 2022 7:49 am All very interesting and it supports the use of plated columns for flavored spirits, especially if they are to be consumed white.

The reduction on 2 plates caught my eye too. Your hypotheses seem feasible but more experiments would probably be needed to fully vet those. Wish I had the time/resources to do that!

Thanks again.

TwoSheds.
I think this analysis (performed by Vinquiry Laboratories) is the result of a one time single sample of distillate from each of the the 3 systems.
I totally agree that multiples should be submitted with enough controls put in place to ensure that the result is as close to an apples to apples comparison. I have no idea beyond the grain bill being identical for each system.
Trample the injured and hurdle the dead.
Setsumi
Distiller
Posts: 1473
Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2010 10:23 pm
Location: Central South Africa

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Setsumi »

LWTCS wrote: ↑Tue Aug 02, 2022 6:47 am
TwoSheds wrote: ↑Tue Aug 02, 2022 5:37 am
LWTCS wrote: ↑Tue Aug 02, 2022 3:14 am If you click back on the table I posted it should be a bit more clear.
Much better. Thanks.

Trying to interpret your results, did you end up with more fusels in the output with the 6 plate than with 2 plates or pot (none)?
Hi TwoSheds,
On the Distilled Beverage Panel we can see that increasing the distillation cycles associated with the higher plate count reduces Acetaldehyde, Methanol, and Ethyl Acetate. That seems quite consistent with the anecdotal information found through out the forum as plated column use became popular. And packed columns too for that matter. Basically more plates (actual or theoretical) equals a thinner finished spirit on paper.
Then on the Fusel Oils panel we can see a steady increase in nearly all fusels, particularly with the 6 plate column.

I do find that the reduction in n-Propanol, Isobutanol, Isoamyl Alcohol and Active Amyl Alcohol with the two plate column very interesting and have no idea precisely why that happens compared to the marked increase of the 6 plate column?
I can only assume the the equalization period often used on the taller column was proportionately longer?

or shorter in relation to the vapour/production speed.
Or that the heat needed to drive vapor to maintain uniform collection speed was that much greater for the 6 plate column and therefore the added heat may have pushed proportionately more fusel constituents into the taller column as the run progressed? yes!? My gut feel.... recently I changed a boiler to bigger volume, but run the same strip volume. I need more energy to keep my plates loaded in the bigger boiler with same charge as the smaller boiler.... i think if i equalize longer it may be better.
Dunno?
My first flute
My press
My twins
My controller
My wife tells me I fell from heaven covered in white. Why did they let me fall?
User avatar
Ben
Distiller
Posts: 1292
Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2020 6:13 am
Location: Colorado

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Ben »

andrew_987789 wrote: ↑Tue Aug 02, 2022 2:54 am
Ben wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 6:13 am
andrew_987789 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 7:17 pm
By the nature of it's design a 2" bubble plate is going to have lower rate of vapor throughput compared to the column, I'm sure.
Incorrect. You will produce the same volume of vapor for a given heat input regardless of the diameter of the system, the vapor speed increases if the available cross section decreases. This is true as long as you aren't pressurizing the system. Liquid behavior coming back down is a different story.
I'm not talking about the amount of vapour produced by the boiler. I'm talking about the amount of vapor that will pass through a 2" bubble plate without additional resistance/back pressure as compared to packed column.
Backpressure specifically refers to resistance of a gas traveling through tubing at a given velocity, we are talking about a plate which has a very small wall surface area, and consequently very small backpressure. There is backpressure generated elsewhere in the system but that has very little to do with the plates.

The "rate" or velocity of the vapor will increase as the total orifice size gets smaller, Bernoulli tells us it has no choice.

There is always a pressure differential between the boiler and the atmosphere, there has to be or gas would not flow.

How about an example on a 2" plate:

Assuming a 7% surface area plate (most are 7-10%). A 2" circle is 12.57"^2, open area will be around 0.88".

Assume the plate is being run in a loaded state, and there is a half inch of liquid on top of it. In order to maintain that half inch head there is ≈0.014 psi between the top plate and the plate below it, or between the plate and the boiler if you are using just one plate. Pressure compounds so there will be higher and higher pressures as the plates stack up.

Lets say we increase our power to the boiler to double this pressure below the plate, to a whopping 0.024 psi, that gives us 0.014 psi of pressure to push the gas with. 0.014psi though an open area of 0.88"^2 means a flow rate of about 6.5 CFM. Ethanol has a vapor density of 1.59 at 180f, so it weighs approximately .13 lbs/cf. So we can push .845lbs of ethanol per minute, while keeping a plate modestly loaded at 1/2" of depth. Ethanol is about 7 lbs per gallon, so you are capable of pushing around a pint per minute of liquid ethanol, in vapor form through that plate.

The actual volume of ethanol vapor is higher than this, that backpressure you mentioned earlier exists on all of the column walls and is even more significant in your LM condenser. Again, pressures are compounded through the system (again, PV=nRT, if the pressure goes up the gas density increases). There is no such thing as a zero pressure still, but we do run open systems, that are freely vented to the atmosphere, and the pressures are quite small.

You could rework this math to say I want to take off X amount of liquid at a given speed, what will the pressure below my top plate be. To get really precise there would be some other math involved but you could get a pretty good estimate of the pressure in the system without it.

So yes, the plate is a "restriction" but not a practical one, in order to reach significant levels of pressure you would have to run a lot of power into the boiler, and the takeoff rate and knockdown requirements would be pretty high.

More on focus of the topic, and taking off at a reasonable rate, larger plates = more production with longer dwell times for the plates. If you are trying to increase purity you don't want a lot of velocity (rate, output, whatever). You should size your plates to the available power, and desired run speed.
:)
Post Reply