Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Vapor, Liquid or Cooling Management. Flutes, plates, etc.

Moderator: Site Moderator

andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

Hey all,

I currently have a 2" packed column and am playing with the idea of adding a bubble ball to it for experimentation as a tails trap.

By the nature of it's design a 2" bubble plate is going to have lower rate of vapor throughput compared to the column, I'm sure.

My question is, what size bubble plate is going to be appropriate to achieve the above, without restricting throughput to the above 2" column.

4" ?

3" seems potentially borderline / not enough?

Any larger than 4" I expect may be overkill?

Thanks in advance for sharing any experience.
drmiller100
Rumrunner
Posts: 694
Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 9:13 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by drmiller100 »

Bubble ball????
Now I know how you claim azeo so easy, it's based on a meat thermometer. :lol:
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

Yep. In short, you have your boiler, a single bubble plate section, then your preferred still head/column on top.

The intended effect is that the bubble plate section works to trap/compress tails into a smaller section towards the end of the run.

Have a read here - viewtopic.php?t=31896
User avatar
Stonecutter
Distiller
Posts: 2146
Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2021 2:40 pm
Location: Somewhere within the Milkyway

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Stonecutter »

No sense starting small.
If you are able, start with 4” you could always compare results with a 3” later.
Good luck :thumbup:
Freedom had been hunted round the globe; reason was considered as rebellion; and the slavery of fear had made men afraid to think. But such is the irresistible nature of truth, that all it asks, and all it wants, is the liberty of appearing.
-Thomas Paine
User avatar
bcook608
Rumrunner
Posts: 686
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2022 8:54 pm
Location: Midwest, USA

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by bcook608 »

andrew_987789 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 8:11 pm Have a read here - viewtopic.php?t=31896
Looks like he was using a 4" Bubble plate sandwiched between 2 4x2 reducers with a sight glass.
User avatar
Yummyrum
Admin
Posts: 10571
Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Yummyrum »

Not sure I understand why you would want to trap tails at the bottom of the column . It makes more sense to let them fall back into the boiler unless for some bazaar reason you might want a trace of tails in your product .
User avatar
bcook608
Rumrunner
Posts: 686
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2022 8:54 pm
Location: Midwest, USA

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by bcook608 »

Yummyrum wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 9:25 pm Not sure I understand why you would want to trap tails at the bottom of the column . It makes more sense to let them fall back into the boiler unless for some bazaar reason you might want a trace of tails in your product .
for a one and done whiskey that sounds like it would be beneficial?
Maybe I'm wrong though. I'm still just a simple Pot head :lol:
User avatar
Saltbush Bill
Global moderator
Posts: 11648
Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2011 2:13 am
Location: Northern NSW Australia

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Saltbush Bill »

I'm with Yummy, if you want less tails but them back in the boiler, a longer column, and or ,more reflux/ lower take off speed will achieve the same thing. A plated section below the packed wont work any better, and maybe not as well , as utilizing the same amount of space/ height with extra packed column.
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

Yummyrum wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 9:25 pm Not sure I understand why you would want to trap tails at the bottom of the column . It makes more sense to let them fall back into the boiler unless for some bazaar reason you might want a trace of tails in your product .
Experimentation. Fun. Knowledge. Why the hell not try it :D
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

bcook608 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 9:37 pm for a one and done whiskey that sounds like it would be beneficial?
Maybe I'm wrong though. I'm still just a simple Pot head :lol:
Fun to try in any case. Never let the nay-sayers talk you out of trying things :wink:
Last edited by andrew_987789 on Sun Jul 31, 2022 2:24 am, edited 1 time in total.
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

Saltbush Bill wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 10:32 pm A plated section below the packed wont work any better, and maybe not as well , as utilizing the same amount of space/ height with extra packed column.
I hear you, though I've done all that.

Have run my column as is, and with extensions, to be 12:1 ratio in height, 21:1 in height, and 25:1 in height. Fully packed in each instance.

Now interested in the potential effects of running it through a liquid fill plate as opposed to a packed column. :idea:
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

bcook608 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 8:37 pm Looks like he was using a 4" Bubble plate sandwiched between 2 4x2 reducers with a sight glass.
That sounds around right in my mental-math too.
User avatar
Saltbush Bill
Global moderator
Posts: 11648
Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2011 2:13 am
Location: Northern NSW Australia

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Saltbush Bill »

Go for it ......no one stopping you......you asked for opinions you got them.
Fact remains the same , it wont trap tails any better than more length and packing.
andrew_987789
Novice
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri May 20, 2022 6:29 pm

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by andrew_987789 »

Saltbush Bill wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 1:22 am Go for it ......no one stopping you......you asked for opinions you got them.
Indeed I did. And while well-intentioned input is welcome, several of the comments have not actually touched on my question.

Alternative theories to using a bubble ball do not equal experience in using one.
Saltbush Bill wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 1:22 am Fact remains the same , it wont trap tails any better than more length and packing.
That may well turn out to be the case. Though there is reading about something on the internet, and there is completing the experience yourself; the former is far less valuable, I'm sure you'd agree :wink:

The question remains, what size bubble ball to play with while maintaining the same throughput :)
User avatar
Saltbush Bill
Global moderator
Posts: 11648
Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2011 2:13 am
Location: Northern NSW Australia

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Saltbush Bill »

Imo ball or plate size will be less important than having a down commer / down commers that can easily handle the volume of returning reflux.
That will be the bottleneck in the system, Id go 3 inch minimum. Perforated plates or bubble caps that are even remotely flooded will always preform at way less than optimum and will let tails through. Id also suggest that at the speed that a normal 2 inch reflux column can process quality booze that a 4 inch plate is probably not necessary.....again downcomer performance is what will dictate the outcome.
andrew_987789 wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 2:39 am Alternative theories to using a bubble ball do not equal experience in using one.
Some may look at them as alternate theories....others may look at them as unsuccessful experiments conducted by many people in the past.
User avatar
Yummyrum
Admin
Posts: 10571
Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Yummyrum »

bcook608 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 9:37 pm
Yummyrum wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 9:25 pm Not sure I understand why you would want to trap tails at the bottom of the column . It makes more sense to let them fall back into the boiler unless for some bazaar reason you might want a trace of tails in your product .
for a one and done whiskey that sounds like it would be beneficial?
Maybe I'm wrong though. I'm still just a simple Pot head :lol:
OK , that sounds fair . I have to say that the intense Butanol from the tails that I get when I drink Jack Daniels is certainly a characteristic taste and I can understand that as a reason to want to do that .

I was basing my comments assuming that most that use a packed reflux still are after a Neutral spirit devoid of any hint of tails .

I guess we don’t all run packed stills purely for Neutral .
GrumbleStill
Swill Maker
Posts: 292
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2021 4:11 am
Location: On the limit of an endless ocean.

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by GrumbleStill »

Hi Andrew,

The question you have asked is what size plate to maintain throughput of your column. TBH, it seems like you may have left out some important information that would help answer your question. Most importantly, what throughput are you currently getting?

The reference design, the “Bitch”, didn’t have a column at all, just the 4” bubble ball and shotgun dephlag parked under the riser of a regular milk can pot still. It looked kinda awesome, and I guess probably allowed the operator to push his pot a bit harder without compromising quality.

Putting the plate under a packed column is a different animal, and knowing the performance of the column might help the experts point you in the right direction.

Cheers
Grumbles.
User avatar
shadylane
Master of Distillation
Posts: 12870
Joined: Sat Oct 27, 2007 11:54 pm
Location: Hiding In the Boiler room of the Insane asylum

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by shadylane »

andrew_987789 wrote: ↑Sun Jul 31, 2022 2:39 am

The question remains, what size bubble ball to play with while maintaining the same throughput :)

I'd get a 6" ball with bubble cap plates.
Bubble caps can be turned down low if needed to match the 2" column.
If you're going to use the plate for a tails trap. It would be best if it was big and driven gently.
User avatar
LWTCS
Site Mod
Posts: 13301
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 6:04 pm
Location: Treasure Coast

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by LWTCS »

The bubbleball concept is not really about a tails trap at all.

It's more to do with boosting the proof of what is feeding the column.
The debate about bubble balls was that they take up more height with only a single plate to show for it compared to the same height of packed column. Theoretically, the addition of one plate shouldn't really have a profound impact on a well spec'd packed column.
And yet minime was able to conclusively demonstrate that the bubbleball addition to the base of his column absolutely hacked his temp gradient by allowing his column temps (particularly at the base) to remain lower for a longer period of time. This isn't speculation. He logged and posted the data over at the Artisan site.

What is speculation is why does this happen when within the same height, packing will provide more theoretical plates?
My theory why this happens has always been about heat management.
It takes X amount of heat to flash alcohol in a kettle with say a 10% abv. After that first phase change cycle occurs what is the typical, approximate abv of the resulting condensed vapor? 35%? 50%? 70%?
It doesn't really matter. The point is that it is definitely higher than the original abv in the kettle. In fact the resulting vapor will always be higher abv than what remains in the kettle at every stage of the run.
And so now it will take that much less heat to flash alcohol at this next plate level. But what happens to the surplus heat needed to create vapor in the kettle? Well usually it will infiltrate the base of the column and exert itself upward.

The column packing typically retains less liquid mass for the same amount of height occupied by the liquid bed on a plate. And therefore the liquid bed on the plate has the ability (capacitance) to store more heat. Basically act as a heat sink or a break. And since it is the abv on the plate that will determine the flash point of the next phase change cycle, it is my assertion that the deeper liquid bed on the actual plate acts as a better heat sink and helps the column cope with what would otherwise be unneeded heat. Heat that would prevent the column from performing optimal separation.

So it's not really about the measly contribution that one single phase change cycle provides. It's more about more precisely managing the heat entering the base of the column and allowing more of the packing to more precisely separate inspite of it's otherwise limited turndown ratio.
Trample the injured and hurdle the dead.
User avatar
Ben
Distiller
Posts: 1292
Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2020 6:13 am
Location: Colorado

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Ben »

andrew_987789 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 7:17 pm
By the nature of it's design a 2" bubble plate is going to have lower rate of vapor throughput compared to the column, I'm sure.
Incorrect. You will produce the same volume of vapor for a given heat input regardless of the diameter of the system, the vapor speed increases if the available cross section decreases. This is true as long as you aren't pressurizing the system. Liquid behavior coming back down is a different story.
:)
Oatmeal
Swill Maker
Posts: 362
Joined: Sat Jun 19, 2021 5:28 am
Location: Colordo

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Oatmeal »

So I bilt one in an 8" sphere. The plate is 6.37". This was modeled after the fu man build. The long and the short of it, is it was one of the better dumb impulses I've had.

Just ran it last night under a short packed 3" column to make rum.

The run before that I ran a 1 and done rum run + feints, quite barbarously in 3 hours and still turned out a decent finished product.

Prefer the pot for whiskey, as the hybrid column made a lighter flavor than I'd prefer.

In sum, build a big one. I'm likely to build another for a hybrid inline column thumper/retort...
Through the magic of alchemy, our spirits live on.
User avatar
Stonecutter
Distiller
Posts: 2146
Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2021 2:40 pm
Location: Somewhere within the Milkyway

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Stonecutter »

I’ve always thought a thin layer of raschig rings at the top of the column was the best type of hybrid for a whiskey. You can always add more if you want it lighter. The trick is the type of screen used to retain them. I’ve not experimented with the marbles (smooth or rough) yet.
Double runs are hard to beat though
Freedom had been hunted round the globe; reason was considered as rebellion; and the slavery of fear had made men afraid to think. But such is the irresistible nature of truth, that all it asks, and all it wants, is the liberty of appearing.
-Thomas Paine
User avatar
Stonecutter
Distiller
Posts: 2146
Joined: Fri Apr 16, 2021 2:40 pm
Location: Somewhere within the Milkyway

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Stonecutter »

I’ve used the rings on my spirit run as well. Small bit to make a lighter spirit. Reminds me of when Finland under control of Russia classified Whiskey as a neutral.
Freedom had been hunted round the globe; reason was considered as rebellion; and the slavery of fear had made men afraid to think. But such is the irresistible nature of truth, that all it asks, and all it wants, is the liberty of appearing.
-Thomas Paine
User avatar
LWTCS
Site Mod
Posts: 13301
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 6:04 pm
Location: Treasure Coast

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by LWTCS »

drmiller100 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 7:47 pm Bubble ball????
Just a nickname for an add on pair of joined half spheres with a bubble cap plate separating each hemisphere.
It was an early experiment that came on the heels of the Magic Flute popularity.
It was just a single plate section that had a cool aesthetic.
Later replaced by the Torpedo, also a single plate add on component.
Trample the injured and hurdle the dead.
Setsumi
Distiller
Posts: 1473
Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2010 10:23 pm
Location: Central South Africa

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Setsumi »

drmiller100 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 30, 2022 7:47 pm Bubble ball????
There was Fu Man.
viewtopic.php?f=17&t=29940
My first flute
My press
My twins
My controller
My wife tells me I fell from heaven covered in white. Why did they let me fall?
User avatar
bluefish_dist
Distiller
Posts: 1503
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2015 10:13 am
Location: Eastern Ia

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by bluefish_dist »

I aLways ran one under my vodka column. I just happened to make my still opening 6” and would put a plate on the opening then attach the column which happened to be 4” or 6”. I would do a 4” at minimum for a 2” column. Never tried mixed packing and plate with a flavored spirit.
Formerly
Dsp-CO-20051
User avatar
TwoSheds
Rumrunner
Posts: 587
Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2021 5:49 pm
Location: New England, USA

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by TwoSheds »

FWIW, and I know it's not exactly the same, but I ran some neutral through 3 plates and 18" of raschig rings, all 3". I managed to pull 95% off the spout, which was part of the goal (I didn't have enough rings for a higher packed section) but the heads/hearts/tails separation wasn't as good as when I run through 36" of rings in my 2" section and the overall product was slightly less neutral, though still usable.

So, again for neutral, I'm back in the search for SPP, but if I can't find it before I need more neutral then I'll buy a few more liters of Raschig rings and do a longer column.
User avatar
LWTCS
Site Mod
Posts: 13301
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 6:04 pm
Location: Treasure Coast

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by LWTCS »

TwoSheds wrote: ↑Mon Aug 01, 2022 6:05 am FWIW, and I know it's not exactly the same, but I ran some neutral through 3 plates and 18" of raschig rings, all 3". I managed to pull 95% off the spout, which was part of the goal (I didn't have enough rings for a higher packed section) but the heads/hearts/tails separation wasn't as good as when I run through 36" of rings in my 2" section and the overall product was slightly less neutral, though still usable.

So, again for neutral, I'm back in the search for SPP, but if I can't find it before I need more neutral then I'll buy a few more liters of Raschig rings and do a longer column.
Actually, this makes more sense than the plates providing a "Tails Trap". Plates are well known to trap and hold tails constituents.
I have posted this analysis previously to illustrate.
Analysis.png

Shoot sorry for the lousy scale of the attachment.
All three of the stills ran the same beer. And presumably the same or similar power input.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Trample the injured and hurdle the dead.
User avatar
Yummyrum
Admin
Posts: 10571
Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by Yummyrum »

This any better
70DEDA22-AA14-425C-A3D5-D32862C978B4.jpeg
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
User avatar
TwoSheds
Rumrunner
Posts: 587
Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2021 5:49 pm
Location: New England, USA

Re: Bubble plate section size to maintain throughput on 2" packed column

Post by TwoSheds »

Yummyrum wrote: ↑Mon Aug 01, 2022 1:09 pm This any better
Nope...
Post Reply