All molasses rum?
Moderator: Site Moderator
-
Glock19Fan
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 6:38 pm
- Location: Southwest Asia/TN
All molasses rum?
When it starts warming up, I am thinking about starting up again. But this time I want to try an all molasses rum. However, my hydrometer broke over the summer, so I dont really have any way of measure SG (but from what I heard measuring in a molasses wash the readings are unreliable).
But my aim is to make a ~12 gallon wash, and I have 5 gallons of molasses to do it with. Each TBSP of molasses contains 11 grams of sugar for what its worth. My yeast tends to ferment out to about 14 percent.
So my question is would I be fine just mixing the 5 gallons of molasses with 7 gallons of water, and pitching the yeast and nutrient like normal? Or would you guys recommend a different amount of water, or adding the molasses at small amounts at a time?
My end goal is to distill in two 6 gallon runs, and collect about 5-6 quarts with each run.
But my aim is to make a ~12 gallon wash, and I have 5 gallons of molasses to do it with. Each TBSP of molasses contains 11 grams of sugar for what its worth. My yeast tends to ferment out to about 14 percent.
So my question is would I be fine just mixing the 5 gallons of molasses with 7 gallons of water, and pitching the yeast and nutrient like normal? Or would you guys recommend a different amount of water, or adding the molasses at small amounts at a time?
My end goal is to distill in two 6 gallon runs, and collect about 5-6 quarts with each run.
Cool guy
-
ArkyJ
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 461
- Joined: Tue Oct 19, 2010 6:08 pm
Re: All molasses rum?
A gallon of molasses weighs what? 8 or 9 pounds. Molasses is 40% to 50% sugar. .5 times 8 = 4pounds of sugar times 5gallons of molasses is 20pounds of sugar in 7gallons of water. Kinda think your yeast is going to scream murder as it dies the second day and you wonder about a stuck ferment.
Might dump a gallon and a half at first and then increase on day 3 with the other half gallon. Day 5 check then to see if ferement is sweet or dry.
ArkyJ who wishes she had paid more attention in 3rd grade.
Might dump a gallon and a half at first and then increase on day 3 with the other half gallon. Day 5 check then to see if ferement is sweet or dry.
ArkyJ who wishes she had paid more attention in 3rd grade.
If it wasn't for bad luck, I wouldn't have any at all.
-
Dnderhead
- Angel's Share

- Posts: 13666
- Joined: Sun Dec 23, 2007 8:07 pm
- Location: up north
Re: All molasses rum?
A US gallon of molasses weighs 12LB..
water-10 LB
something like milk -8LB.
water-10 LB
something like milk -8LB.
-
Glock19Fan
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 6:38 pm
- Location: Southwest Asia/TN
Re: All molasses rum?
According to the label;
1 TBSP = 21 grams
21g x 260 servings = 5460 grams
5460/ 454 = 12.026 LBS
So each gallon of molasses weighs 12LBS
1 TBSP = 11 grams sugar
11g x 260 = 2860
2860/ 454 = 6.3
So each gallon contains 6.3 grams of sugar.
A typical "job" for my yeast is 25LBS total sugar per 10 gallon wash.
So,
5 x 6.3 = 31.5 sugar for a 12 gallon wash.
That equals to 26.145 LBS sugar per 10 gallons, or as stated above, 31.5LBS for a 12 gallon wash.
So, becuase of this I am thinking 5 gallons of molasses in a 12 gallon wash wouldnt be too out of the ordinary would it?
1 TBSP = 21 grams
21g x 260 servings = 5460 grams
5460/ 454 = 12.026 LBS
So each gallon of molasses weighs 12LBS
1 TBSP = 11 grams sugar
11g x 260 = 2860
2860/ 454 = 6.3
So each gallon contains 6.3 grams of sugar.
A typical "job" for my yeast is 25LBS total sugar per 10 gallon wash.
So,
5 x 6.3 = 31.5 sugar for a 12 gallon wash.
That equals to 26.145 LBS sugar per 10 gallons, or as stated above, 31.5LBS for a 12 gallon wash.
So, becuase of this I am thinking 5 gallons of molasses in a 12 gallon wash wouldnt be too out of the ordinary would it?
Cool guy
-
ArkyJ
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 461
- Joined: Tue Oct 19, 2010 6:08 pm
Re: All molasses rum?
Good luck to you and wish you well on the run. But, go to the parent site and do the math. I think your using twice or more of the sugar than you need. I could be wrong. Won't be the first time, errr, 1000 times. Well, maybe more.
ArkyJ
ArkyJ
If it wasn't for bad luck, I wouldn't have any at all.
-
Barney Fife
- Distiller
- Posts: 1249
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:20 am
- Location: Mayberry, NC
Re: All molasses rum?
Buy yourself another hydrometer before you waste all your molasses.... And our time. Yes, the hydro will not read zero when the washes are done, but you'll still know when they are done because you'll not see a change in two days. Otherwise, you can be fooled by a stuck wash. and yeast don't care how much sugar and solids are in the wash; they care about the total SG, so yes, you still need one.
Yeah, you'll kill the yeast right away with that. One gallon of molasses to 12 gallons water would be close to ideal. Mix it with hot water. Once cooled, take a SG reading and use white sugar to bring it up to 1.060 if necessary. Run the strip run as hard as you can; as much power as you have, or as much as your condenser will take. Save this...
Use ALL the dunder, and add it back to the trubs left behind when you charged the boiler. add to this a 1/2 gallon of molasses, and white sugar to bring the SG again to 1.060. Again, run as hard as you can, save it and set it aside next to the first runs', and re-use all the dunder back over the trubs again, this time with a quart, quart ad a half of molasses, and as much white sugar as you need to get it to 1.040 this time. You want to use less molasses each time because there's a lot of solids still left in the trubs and dunder, and the molasses flavor is becoming more and more concentrated with each generation. Also, by the 3rd generation, you'll need to shoot for a lower SG as you're wash will become slower and slower, so be nice to the yeast, and go easy on them. I can get 5 to 6 generations this way.
On the final generation of the washes, charge the boiler as usual, but now add ALL the saved up feints from the previous strip runs. Runs this one hard, but make your cuts carefully; I run it slow through the heads, and once into the hearts, wide open! Save the heads and tails, and once you have enough of these saved up from a few full generations' runs, run them together in a column still to squeeze out the heads real well, and you'll enjoy a nice, light yet full bodied rum. Save the tails from this and use them with other rums as you wish; the tails are always good, but toss the heads into the "window cleaner/fire starter jar" after all of this.
Enjoy!
Remember, be nice to the yeast, and they'll be nice to you.
Yeah, you'll kill the yeast right away with that. One gallon of molasses to 12 gallons water would be close to ideal. Mix it with hot water. Once cooled, take a SG reading and use white sugar to bring it up to 1.060 if necessary. Run the strip run as hard as you can; as much power as you have, or as much as your condenser will take. Save this...
Use ALL the dunder, and add it back to the trubs left behind when you charged the boiler. add to this a 1/2 gallon of molasses, and white sugar to bring the SG again to 1.060. Again, run as hard as you can, save it and set it aside next to the first runs', and re-use all the dunder back over the trubs again, this time with a quart, quart ad a half of molasses, and as much white sugar as you need to get it to 1.040 this time. You want to use less molasses each time because there's a lot of solids still left in the trubs and dunder, and the molasses flavor is becoming more and more concentrated with each generation. Also, by the 3rd generation, you'll need to shoot for a lower SG as you're wash will become slower and slower, so be nice to the yeast, and go easy on them. I can get 5 to 6 generations this way.
On the final generation of the washes, charge the boiler as usual, but now add ALL the saved up feints from the previous strip runs. Runs this one hard, but make your cuts carefully; I run it slow through the heads, and once into the hearts, wide open! Save the heads and tails, and once you have enough of these saved up from a few full generations' runs, run them together in a column still to squeeze out the heads real well, and you'll enjoy a nice, light yet full bodied rum. Save the tails from this and use them with other rums as you wish; the tails are always good, but toss the heads into the "window cleaner/fire starter jar" after all of this.
Enjoy!
Remember, be nice to the yeast, and they'll be nice to you.
-
Dnderhead
- Angel's Share

- Posts: 13666
- Joined: Sun Dec 23, 2007 8:07 pm
- Location: up north
Re: All molasses rum?
float a egg, a egg will brake the surface about 1.070/9%-1080/10%
not real accurate but better than nothing.
not real accurate but better than nothing.
-
rad14701
- retired
- Posts: 20865
- Joined: Wed Dec 19, 2007 4:46 pm
- Location: New York, USA
Re: All molasses rum?
Which equates to: ~17.6% ABV...A typical "job" for my yeast is 25LBS total sugar per 10 gallon wash.
Which equates to: ~18.5% ABV31.5 sugar for a 12 gallon wash.
I think something is drastically flawed in your math and logic and it may start with:
So each gallon contains 6.3 grams of sugar.
-
beelah
- Trainee
- Posts: 758
- Joined: Fri Jun 26, 2009 10:38 am
- Location: West Coast of Canada
Re: All molasses rum?
Thanks for that info Barney. I just ran me two rum washes but only used about 2 gallons of dunder on the second batch and I noted a signifigant improvement on the the aroma of the spirit...much more rummmy like especially as it was getting into the tails.
I am going to have to pack away my equipment as we are packing the house up to put it on the market, and don't wnat any looky-loos getting funny ideas about what I am doing with all these beer kegs, copper pipe and propane burners all hanging out with my carboys and fermentation tubs.
I am going to have to ration out what I have in storage from now until late summer when I can set up my new stillin room at my new place up the coast.
I have primarily been running bran fake/sugar washes and have done a couple of cornmeal-malted barley whiskeys lately that tastes really nice after a few months on oak.
When I get set up again I am going to do a series of rum washes and try your suggestion in this post and see what success I get.
I am going to have to pack away my equipment as we are packing the house up to put it on the market, and don't wnat any looky-loos getting funny ideas about what I am doing with all these beer kegs, copper pipe and propane burners all hanging out with my carboys and fermentation tubs.
I am going to have to ration out what I have in storage from now until late summer when I can set up my new stillin room at my new place up the coast.
I have primarily been running bran fake/sugar washes and have done a couple of cornmeal-malted barley whiskeys lately that tastes really nice after a few months on oak.
When I get set up again I am going to do a series of rum washes and try your suggestion in this post and see what success I get.
-
Glock19Fan
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 6:38 pm
- Location: Southwest Asia/TN
Re: All molasses rum?
Ok, I agree, I went back and checked, and I believe that when calculating the % yeilds, I was using quarts instead of liters.rad14701 wrote:Which equates to: ~17.6% ABV...A typical "job" for my yeast is 25LBS total sugar per 10 gallon wash.
Which equates to: ~18.5% ABV31.5 sugar for a 12 gallon wash.
I think something is drastically flawed in your math and logic and it may start with:So each gallon contains 6.3 grams of sugar.
And I posted that pretty late last night, IIRC around 1130, so that doesnt help either.
I will do a little brainstorming to figure out just what I want, and I have decided to get a hydrometer becuase I am running low on yeast anyway.
Barney- I am wanting to try to do an all molasses wash, so I am going to try to avoid using sugar if I can. But I do have some dunder saved up, and may give it a try with this next batch.
Just curious, but does anyone know if large commercial companies add sugar to their wash?
Cool guy
-
Barney Fife
- Distiller
- Posts: 1249
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:20 am
- Location: Mayberry, NC
Re: All molasses rum?
Production rum is made with all-molasses, but they only shoot for a 4 to 5% ABV wash. Trying for more than that with all-molasses brings the SG too high and hurts the yeast. If you insist on using only molasses, expect low yield washes like these. On the other hand, using a reasonable amount of molasses and using white sugar, we can safely do rum washes at 9 to 10% ABV. Since they buy molasses so dirt cheap, production rum makers make large batches and are happy with their 5% washes, since for them, sugar would be relatively very expensive. For us, sugar is cheaper than molasses, so there's no reason not to use it. Besides, if we think back to the olden days of rums, the technology of sugar extraction was much more crude than it is today, and molasses had a much higher sugar content; think of the addition of white sugar to your molasses wash as putting back some of the sugars lost to modern extraction methods.
And I assure you that my rum is a damn sight better than the run of the mill, off the shelf rums, and I'll put it side by side with some of the best high end rums.
And I assure you that my rum is a damn sight better than the run of the mill, off the shelf rums, and I'll put it side by side with some of the best high end rums.
-
Glock19Fan
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 6:38 pm
- Location: Southwest Asia/TN
Re: All molasses rum?
Barney- The issue about the sugar content is one I brought up in a previous thread. I was curious if adding sugar to a heavy blackstrap molasses wash would produce similar flavors as a fancy type molasses.
The main reason I wanted to do an all molasses rum is becuase I wanted to see how close I could come to off the shelf rums, but personally I think what I have right now is really close, but mainly becuase of my tails collection (I ran fairly pretty heavy in both batches).
While I am still not decided on whether to do an all molasses wash or not, I dont think this time I will use so many tails. This will be the third time my barrel will be used, and I think along with the relativly light charred flavor, I would like to have a lighter bodied rum.
The main reason I wanted to do an all molasses rum is becuase I wanted to see how close I could come to off the shelf rums, but personally I think what I have right now is really close, but mainly becuase of my tails collection (I ran fairly pretty heavy in both batches).
While I am still not decided on whether to do an all molasses wash or not, I dont think this time I will use so many tails. This will be the third time my barrel will be used, and I think along with the relativly light charred flavor, I would like to have a lighter bodied rum.
Cool guy
-
Barney Fife
- Distiller
- Posts: 1249
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 5:20 am
- Location: Mayberry, NC
Re: All molasses rum?
If you want a lighter rum, use more sugar, less molasses.
I'm not understanding your fear of sugar...
I'm not understanding your fear of sugar...
-
Glock19Fan
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 6:38 pm
- Location: Southwest Asia/TN
Re: All molasses rum?
No fear, just wanted to try a "traditional" rum with all molasses, although I do understand the various sugar levels of the molasses over different time periods as well as manufactoring processes.
I think I will try a small batch of all molasses, fermenting to 5-6%, and see how it turns out before using all of it. Of course when i get a hydrometer.
I think I will try a small batch of all molasses, fermenting to 5-6%, and see how it turns out before using all of it. Of course when i get a hydrometer.
Cool guy
-
Glock19Fan
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 6:38 pm
- Location: Southwest Asia/TN
Re: All molasses rum?
A hydrometer along with some more yeast is on the way, so I plan on making a wash sometime in the next few weeks. I will keep you guys posted.
Cool guy
-
Yodaspike
- Novice
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat May 23, 2020 10:35 am
- Location: S.A
Re: All molasses rum?
Hi all
And a mery x-mas
So i took 100lt of water 50kg is 43% molasses 4 ltof inverted sugar(10kg in 5lt water) another 20lt of water(to dissolve all molasses left in bucket) 1kg oeaches and 4 oranges. In a tum wash.
Sg reading 1130, 1 week later at 1050, still bubling tegularly, but sg dropping very slow, beer yeast of prooven abv of 15%. Should i let it go on or just run it?
Droped in 4 days to about 1056, another 3 days and on 1050, starting to wonder if another 3% is worth waiting 2 weeks or more.
Thanks
And a mery x-mas
So i took 100lt of water 50kg is 43% molasses 4 ltof inverted sugar(10kg in 5lt water) another 20lt of water(to dissolve all molasses left in bucket) 1kg oeaches and 4 oranges. In a tum wash.
Sg reading 1130, 1 week later at 1050, still bubling tegularly, but sg dropping very slow, beer yeast of prooven abv of 15%. Should i let it go on or just run it?
Droped in 4 days to about 1056, another 3 days and on 1050, starting to wonder if another 3% is worth waiting 2 weeks or more.
Thanks
-
JesseMarques
- Bootlegger
- Posts: 114
- Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2020 3:52 pm
- Location: Brasil
Re: All molasses rum?
why you made a 1130og wash? how much yeast did you use?Yodaspike wrote: ↑Fri Dec 18, 2020 12:37 pm Hi all
And a mery x-mas
So i took 100lt of water 50kg is 43% molasses 4 ltof inverted sugar(10kg in 5lt water) another 20lt of water(to dissolve all molasses left in bucket) 1kg oeaches and 4 oranges. In a tum wash.
Sg reading 1130, 1 week later at 1050, still bubling tegularly, but sg dropping very slow, beer yeast of prooven abv of 15%. Should i let it go on or just run it?
Droped in 4 days to about 1056, another 3 days and on 1050, starting to wonder if another 3% is worth waiting 2 weeks or more.
Thanks
For me it looks like a bad recipe, if you are hurry to distill you should make a lower og wash, around 1060 og is nice. The time you already spent you could made 5 or more ferments with lower og
- Yummyrum
- Admin
- Posts: 10580
- Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
- Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie
Re: All molasses rum?
Next time leave the sugar out .
You only need around 7-8% avb for a Rum wash .
Chances are if you run it before its fully fermented it will foam up a lot worse than if you don’t . But if its a stripping run won’t matter .
You only need around 7-8% avb for a Rum wash .
Chances are if you run it before its fully fermented it will foam up a lot worse than if you don’t . But if its a stripping run won’t matter .
My recommended goto .
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
- tubbsy
- Swill Maker
- Posts: 186
- Joined: Mon Jul 22, 2019 10:34 pm
Re: All molasses rum?
Gravity is always higher when using molasses. The OG and FG of 1.130-1.050 for the molasses wash is equivalent to a 1.080-1.000 sugar wash. Still a touch higher than I'd go.JesseMarques wrote: ↑Fri Dec 18, 2020 1:07 pmwhy you made a 1130og wash? how much yeast did you use?Yodaspike wrote: ↑Fri Dec 18, 2020 12:37 pm Hi all
And a mery x-mas
So i took 100lt of water 50kg is 43% molasses 4 ltof inverted sugar(10kg in 5lt water) another 20lt of water(to dissolve all molasses left in bucket) 1kg oeaches and 4 oranges. In a tum wash.
Sg reading 1130, 1 week later at 1050, still bubling tegularly, but sg dropping very slow, beer yeast of prooven abv of 15%. Should i let it go on or just run it?
Droped in 4 days to about 1056, another 3 days and on 1050, starting to wonder if another 3% is worth waiting 2 weeks or more.
Thanks
For me it looks like a bad recipe, if you are hurry to distill you should make a lower og wash, around 1060 og is nice. The time you already spent you could made 5 or more ferments with lower og
Last edited by tubbsy on Fri Dec 18, 2020 1:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Yummyrum
- Admin
- Posts: 10580
- Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2013 2:23 am
- Location: Fraser Coast QLD Aussie
Re: All molasses rum?
My all molases Rums have a start gravity around 1.130 and finish around 1.060 ...... but I use Dunder which has a really high gravity . This bumps the start and end gravitys a lot .
EDIT:
I only check gravity out of curiousity every now and again . Mostly so when someone asks what to expect I can tell them .
When it comes to telling when its done , thats done with a taste test , not a gravity reading .
EDIT:
I only check gravity out of curiousity every now and again . Mostly so when someone asks what to expect I can tell them .
When it comes to telling when its done , thats done with a taste test , not a gravity reading .
My recommended goto .
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
https://homedistiller.org/wiki/index.ph ... ion_Theory
-
Yodaspike
- Novice
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat May 23, 2020 10:35 am
- Location: S.A
Re: All molasses rum?
Yeah think i messed up as i with a sugar wash work on 1076og, so 200gr per lt, thus i use 10kg of sugar with 2-4lt of water to invert then i take 50lt of water and add the syrup, but with the molasses i added the molasses volume to the total wash volume which i think was my mistake, again its still bubling alot, so guess i will have to leave it till it quites down and run it and see.
Did many fruit and sugar and mixed washes, dirst molasses wash, just dont want to cook it and make a mess in my colum.
Just looking for some advice on this...well misshap
Did many fruit and sugar and mixed washes, dirst molasses wash, just dont want to cook it and make a mess in my colum.
Just looking for some advice on this...well misshap
-
Yodaspike
- Novice
- Posts: 97
- Joined: Sat May 23, 2020 10:35 am
- Location: S.A
Re: All molasses rum?
Fyi smells awesome, havent tasted it yet as its still fermenting very well